Victorinox Classic SD Swiss Army Review
Our Verdict
Compare to Similar Products
This Product
Victorinox Classic SD Swiss Army | |||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|
Awards | Best Bang for your Buck | Best on a Tight Budget | |||
Price | $24.00 at REI Compare at 2 sellers | $77 List $57.38 at Amazon | $48 List $48.00 at Amazon | $17.00 List $15.99 at Amazon | $10.00 List $9.95 at Amazon |
Overall Score | |||||
Star Rating | |||||
Bottom Line | A diminutive pocket knife with some helpful features | There's sure to be a colorway that suits you in CIVIVI's lineup. And take confidence that a great knife will come with it no matter what | CRKT designed this knife to be especially portable and included some commendable material selections | A simple, well-made, especially portable option in today's knife market that's small and light enough to forget it's on you, and strong enough to work in a pinch | An affordable, tactical knife that isn't nearly as well constructed as other knives in our lineup |
Rating Categories | Victorinox Classic... | CIVIVI Button Lock... | CRKT Drifter | Gerber Paraframe Mini | Albatross EDC Tactical |
Blade and Edge Integrity (30%) | |||||
Ergonomics (25%) | |||||
Portability (20%) | |||||
Construction Quality (25%) | |||||
Specs | Victorinox Classic... | CIVIVI Button Lock... | CRKT Drifter | Gerber Paraframe Mini | Albatross EDC Tactical |
Blade Length (Measured) | 1.29 in | 2.77 in | 2.75 in | 2.20 in | 2.50 in |
Length Open (Measured) | 3.81 in | 7.05 in | 6.49 in | 5.3 in | 6.50 in |
Length Closed (Measured) | 2.25 in | 4.15 in | 3.65 in | 3.10 in | 3.90 in |
Weight (Measured) | 0.75 oz | 3.15 oz | 2.20 oz | 1.45 oz | 3.80 oz |
Closed Thickness w/o Pocket Clip (Measured) | 0.34 in | 0.52 in | 0.33 in | 0.29 in | 0.40 in |
Blade Style | Drop point, plain edge | Drop point, plain edge | Recurve blade, plain edge | Drop point, plain edge | Drop point, plain edge |
Blade Material | Proprietary stainless steel (between 440A and 420) | Nitro-V stainless steel | D2 stainless steel | High carbon stainless steel | 440 stainless steel |
Closed Blade Lock | No | No | No | No | No |
Open Blade Lock Mechanism | None | Button lock | Liner lock | Frame lock | Liner lock |
Handle Material | Plastic | G10 fiberglass laminate | G10 fiberglass laminate | Stainless steel | Stainless steel |
Opening Style | Fingernail | Flipper (non-assisted) | Flipper (non-assisted), ambidextrous thumb stud | Fingernail | Assisted, flipper |
Carry Style | Keyring | Pocket clip, lanyard hole | Pocket clip, lanyard hole | Pocket clip | Pocket clip |
Other Features Or Functions | Scissors, nail file, small screwdriver, tweezers, toothpick, key ring | Lanyard hole | Lanyard hole | None | Seatbelt cutter, glass breaker |
Our Analysis and Test Results
The Classic SD Swiss Army Knife is a tiny, multi-purpose, well-made piece of equipment. If you hardly have room in your pocket or purse for more than a car key and a house key, the Classic SD should slide in virtually unnoticed. Unnoticed, that is until you need it. Despite the toy-like stature, this little tool packs in function and quality at a very affordable price. It is nearly the smallest in our test but comes with features, each very useful and functional, despite their tiny stature. If you are looking for a knife to virtually disappear on your keychain but roar to practical life whenever you need to tackle some light-duty task - (this could describe a significant portion of the world's citizens) - look no further than the Victorinox Classic SD. If this knife doesn't satisfy your needs, you'll probably want to study up on our best multi-tools review.
Performance Comparison
Blade and Edge Integrity
Victorinox brings a long history of well-made blades to the table. The blade is slim and short and therefore isn't suitable for extended cutting or laborious tasks. However, it is more than adequate for most household and office tasks. Upon initial deployment, the blade seems flimsy. However, in years and years of usage, our testing team has yet to see any failures.
The Swiss Army is well known for two things: Swiss men between the ages of 19 and 34 are required to be trained and equipped to defend their neutral country, and the government commissions the construction of official Swiss Army knives from two domestic manufacturers. Victorinox is one of those producers. Both manufacturers must mark near the base of the main blades of the official knives. The Classic SD model is labeled there with the simple designation “Victorinox Swiss Made Stainless.”
Ergonomics
The Classic SD knife is designed to optimize compactness and versatility. As such, it is not the most ergonomic knife in our test. You won't spend hours cutting with the Classic SD. You won't choose to saw through thick ropes or dress wild game. However, all tools are easily deployed and can be operated to their intended capacity. Each of the three main tools (blade, file/screwdriver, and scissors) is equipped with a simple fingernail cut out and pulls out smoothly with minimal pressure. Even after years and years of pocket-living, the tools fold out easily and smoothly.
A toothpick and a pair of tweezers are encased in the sides of the Classic SD. Each of these pulls out completely and stows away with just a “friction fit” holding them in. It is a testament to the quality of construction that this friction grip remains tight throughout the life and use of a tool like this. Careful and close manufacturing tolerances hold the tools when necessary but give them up when the user wishes to use them. The other tiny knives are similarly compromised in ergonomics. Tiny tools are harder to use than optimally sized ones. We accept this inherent decrease in ergonomics for the symmetrical gain in portability.
Portability
The Classic SD Swiss Army Knife packs a lot of versatility and usefulness compared to other knives we tested. The Classic SD comes right out of the box equipped with a tiny split ring. Threading the included split ring onto your existing key chain leaves the knife free to rotate and nest in amongst your keys while carrying. And then, in usage, you also have some freedom from the keys. The scissors open to the end opposite the key chain. This leaves the keys completely out of the way of scissor usage. The blade and nail file open on the end, adjacent to the key ring attachment. In application, provided you carry no more than five or six keys, you just grasp the whole bundle (keys, ring, knife handle) together while using the blade or file.
Construction Quality
Again, the toy-like specifications belie the durability and quality of this inexpensive knife. Victorinox produces the Classic SD on an economy of scale. Corners are not cut. Rather, they count high volume sales through generations, spreading the love with gifts of Classic SD knives. The high-quality stainless steel throughout, firmly affixed, and colorful side plates, combined with smooth operating hinges, resulting in a tiny tool that inspires confidence. Aside from misplacing tweezers and toothpicks, our testers have had no trouble with the integrity of the Classic SD knife.
Should You Buy the Victorinox Classic SD Swiss Army?
Our testing team's long history with the Victorinox Classic SD knife inspires nostalgia for those first youthful feelings of independence and usefulness. Our lead test editor owned one as a kid and was asked to test one for OutdoorGearLab. In both sessions with the knife, his recommendation would be the same. This is an excellent knife for anyone who otherwise wouldn't bother to carry a blade or pocket tool. We find it remarkable that Victorinox can afford to distribute such a quality piece of equipment at this affordable price. It will last you as long as you can keep track of it, and you'll readily replace it when misplaced.
What Other Pocket Knives Should You Consider?
While the Victorinox Classic SD Swiss Army Knife is truly a classic pocket knife, it likely won't hold up to the requirements of many looking for a daily carry knife. While other options won't have the suite of tools featured on the Classic SD, a knife like the Gerber Paraframe Mini offers similar micro-scale functionality at a similar price point. Another exceptionally portable knife we love as an everyday carry is the Leatherman Skeletool KB.