REASONS TO BUY
Well-insulated
Stylish
Easy zippered access
REASONS TO AVOID
Narrow foot bed
Narrow calf
Seams not fully waterproof
Kamik Rogue Tall Review
A stylish, adjustable and winter-ready boot designed for harsh weather, offering warmth and excellent traction for cold, wet conditions
Credit: Sara James
RELATED: The Best Winter Boots for Women
Our Verdict
The Kamik Rogue Tall stands out in the testing lineup thanks to its ability to combine performance and style. These boots are our favorite when we want to shape-shift, helping us transition quickly from town to trail. The seamed sealed leather can handle heavy rain, puddles, or snow drifts, and the grip XT rubber soles perform on wet or rocky trails. The 200g insulation keeps your feet warm, but the design is also breathable if you build up some heat. With a lace-up and zipper entry option, you can adjust these boots to suit your calf shape and then easily zip in and out of them. The footbed is quite narrow, so if you are looking for a wide shoe, these are unlikely to be the ones for you.
Compare to Similar Products
 This Product
Kamik Rogue Tall | |||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Awards |  Best Overall Winter Boot for Women |  Best Protection for Wet Winters | Best Lightweight Coverage |  Best Bang for the Buck | |
| Price | $180 List $129.95 at Amazon | $96.83 at REI Compare at 3 sellers | $205 List $136.44 at Amazon | $164.95 at Backcountry Compare at 2 sellers | $79.03 at Amazon Compare at 3 sellers |
Overall Score  |
|||||
| Star Rating | |||||
| Bottom Line | A versatile and sleek winter boot built for harsh conditions, providing warmth and superior traction in cold, wet weather | This stellar winter boot excels in the warmth, weather protection, durability, and traction categories | Highly protective, this easy-to-use boot has impressive traction and insulation | A featherweight boot that is ultra warm and offers an impressive amount of leg coverage | Not the most durable or fashionable, but this boot is warm, snowproof, easy to use, and has solid traction |
| Rating Categories | Kamik Rogue Tall | Baffin Chloe | Muck Boot Arctic Ic... | Baffin Escalate X -... | Kamik Momentum 3 |
| Warmth (25%) | |||||
| Weather Protection (25%) | |||||
| Comfort and Fit (20%) | |||||
| Traction (15%) | |||||
| Quality of Construction (15%) | |||||
| Specifications | Kamik Rogue Tall | Baffin Chloe | Muck Boot Arctic Ic... | Baffin Escalate X -... | Kamik Momentum 3 |
| Maximum Puddle Depth Before Major Leaking | 4" | 9.5" | 17" | 11.5" | 3" |
| Measured Weight (per pair) | 3 lb 2 oz (size 9) | 3 lb 3 oz (size 9) | 5 lb 1 oz (size 9) | 1 lb 9 oz (size 9) | 2 lb 10 oz (size 9) |
| Measured Shaft Height (from bottom of sole to top of shaft) | 11 " | 10" | 16" | 11" | 9" |
| Lining/Insulation | HEAT-MX™ 90 sustainable thermal insulation with soft boa lining | Thermaplush wicking layer, B-Tek foam lining, B-Tek Heat lightweight, 4-channel hollow-fibre insulation, vapourized aluminum membrane, polyester wool blend and Hydromax layer |
8mm neoprene and fleece lining | Fixed-Fit multi-layer inner boot system incluging, hollow-fibre insulation form-fitting foam and Thermaplush lining. | Synthetic Heat-MX Insulation |
| Type of Boot | All-around winter wear | All-around winter wear | Winter workwear | All-around winter | Casual winter wear |
| Removable Liner | No | Yes | No | No | No |
| Footbed | CushyStep Everyday EVA | EVA | bioDEWIX | Removal EVA | |
| Upper Material | Seam sealed waterproof leather | Suede leather | Rubber | Nylon | Waterproof nylon |
| Toe Box | Leather | Rubber | Rubber | Reinforced Hex | Rubber |
| Outsole | ASPEN rubber with Grip XT | Polar Rubber | Vibram Arctic Grip A.T. | Polar Rubber and Icebite Grip | ICEKISS rubber outsole |
| Company Claimed Cold Weather Rating | -20°F | -40°F | Not stated | -22°F | -40 °F |
| Animal Products | Yes | Yes | No | No | No |
| Sizes Available | 6-11 | 6 - 11 | 5 - 11 | 6 - 11 | 5 - 11 |
| Features | Availble in 4 colors. Lace up with waterproof zipper and side buckle |
Our Analysis and Test Results
The Kamik's Rogue Tall is our favorite to wear when we want to seamlessly transition from wilderness to urban environments without skipping a step or changing our shoes. With an 11-inch shaft, 200g of insulation, and Grip XT rubber soles, these boots offer great coverage, warmth, and traction. They feature a lace-up closure for a secure fit, while a side-entry zipper allows for quick and easy on-and-off convenience.
Performance Comparison
The lace and zipper entry options was popular with those that wanted a secure fit as well as quick and convenient access.
Credit: Sara James
Warmth
The Kamik Rogue are built for exceptional warmth, making them a reliable choice for cold-weather adventures. Featuring 200g of Heat-MX 90 insulation, they effectively trap heat without adding bulk, with the manufacturers giving them a comfort rating of -4°F. During our ice bath immersion testing, these boots lost heat at a slower rate than many boots that were rated to colder temperatures.
The thick soles and 200g internal insulation helped to keep these boots well insulated from the cold.
Credit: Sara James
The seam-sealed waterproof leather upper helps lock out moisture, preventing heat loss in damp and snowy conditions. Additionally, the faux shearling lining provides an extra layer of insulation and comfort, enhancing warmth while maintaining breathability. Whether navigating icy city streets or trekking through snow-covered trails, these boots offer the protection needed to stay warm in harsh winter environments.
The internal lining adds comfort and warmth to these winter ready boots.
Credit: Sara James
Weather Protection
With a measured shaft height of 11 inches, the Kamik Rogue offers great coverage when walking in snowy conditions. Thanks to the adjustable shaft width, you can ensure a snug fit, preventing snow or cold air from entering the top of the boots. Their seam-sealed waterproof leather effectively repels moisture, keeping feet dry in rain, snow, and slush.
The boots were some of the tallest in our testing line up, offering great coverage from deep snow.
Credit: Sara James
Although these boots beaded off water from rain and puddles, when we waded into a flowing river, the seams and zippers were susceptible to water intrusion. It may be best to avoid river crossings or prolonged immersion in these boots.
When immersed for more than 30 seconds in flowing water, we noticed some water intrusion through the seams.
Credit: Sara James
Comfort and Fit
The Kamik Rogue Tall boots are designed for all-day comfort with a secure yet flexible fit. The lace-up closure allows for adjustability, ensuring a snug feel, while the side-entry zipper provides easy on-and-off convenience. Inside, a soft faux shearling lining adds warmth and cushioning, preventing discomfort from prolonged wear. The removable EVA foam footbed provides cushioned support, though those needing extra arch support may benefit from additional insoles.
Once you have laced these boots to your personalized fit, you can easily zip in and out of them.
Credit: Sara James
While the fit is generally comfortable, the toe box runs slightly narrow, which may not be ideal for wider feet. Despite a brief break-in period, these boots mold to the foot over time, offering a customized fit for both outdoor adventures and urban wear.
Although the laces provide some adjustability, the shaft is generally narrow and not well suited for wider calves.
Credit: Sara James
Traction
The Grip XT rubber outsole provides reliable traction on slippery surfaces, reducing the risk of slipping on ice or wet terrain. The soles sport a deep tread pattern that performs well in snow, ice, and mud.
The Grip XT and deep thread delivered reliable traction on a variety of surfaces.
Credit: Sara James
Quality of Construction
From the strong rubber outsole to the high-quality leather upper, these boots are built to withstand winter's toughest challenges while maintaining style and comfort.
The “sealed seams” did not hold up in flowing water as well as we had hoped.
Credit: Sara James
Our only complaint is that when immersed in flowing water, we noticed water seepage at some of the seams, despite the fact that they are advertised as 'seam sealed'. Interestingly, this was much worse on one boot than the other, leading us to think this was due to inconsistency in manufacturing.
Should You Buy the Kamik Rogue Tall?
The Kamik Rogue Tall boots are a solid investment for those seeking warm, winter-ready, and durable footwear that transitions effortlessly between outdoor adventures and urban settings. However, those with wider feet or high arch support needs may find the fit slightly restrictive. If you need a stylish yet functional winter boot that can handle snow, slush, and ice while keeping you comfortable, the Kamik Rogue Tall is a great choice.
The versatile Rogue's pair well with leggings, under jeans or even with a dress.
Credit: Sara James
What Other Winter Boots Should You Consider?
Considering the design, the Kamik Rogue is relatively easy to get in and out of; however, if you are looking for the speediest slipper in the lineup, the Kamik Momentum 3 is hard to beat, getting you out the door that bit faster. The Kamik Rogue is also not designed for wide feet or calves; if you are looking for a boot with more space to stretch your toes, the Keen Greta Tall has a wider toe box, and the shaft can be adjusted to accommodate a wider shin size comfortably. For those looking for more work-ready boots that can withstand colder temperatures for long days in the snow, The North Face Chilkat V 400 is worthy of your consideration. Although these boots are heavier and take longer to lace up, they offer superior waterproofing, more support, and better traction on ice.
Comfortable, warm and offering great coverage, these are some of our favorite boots to wear.
Credit: Sara James
—Sara James
You Might Also Like
