We buy all the products we test — no freebies from companies. If you purchase through our links, we may earn a commission, which helps support our testing.
After trekking thousands of miles in more than 145 pairs of men's hiking boots and women's hiking boots in the last decade, we have well-informed recommendations for you. In this update, we bought the top 41 men's and women's hiking boots available today and put them to an epic head-to-head test. We designed tests to assess comfort, support, traction, water resistance, weight, and durability performance. We compared materials and construction, dunked each underwater, and weighed each boot on our scales.
In our men's boot testing, no boot impressed us more than the innovative Hoka Kaha 2 GTX hiking boot which takes the cake for comfort. These stable boots offer a super plush sole that absorbs all the impacts of foot strikes on the trail. You will love how they make you feel less tired and sore at the end of the day.
Our top recommendation for women is the La Sportiva Ultra Raptor II. Our expert women hikers found it just as comfortable as the Hoka Kaha 2, which costs the same, but the Ultra Raptor offers better traction and a 16% lighter weight.
We are blown away by the comfort of the Hoka Kaha 2 GTX. Our lead tester, Ryan Huetter, noted, “it feels like you are walking on a cloud.” These boots have two inches of cushiony compression-molded EVA underfoot, which Huetter describes as “absorbing all the impacts of foot strikes on the trail.” Paired with this is a rockered sole that allows for a less jarring stride and gentle spring forward. We took these boots on all types of trails, and we felt comfortable and supported the entire time. The support offered by the Kaha 2 is incredible, thanks to the 7.25-inch tall construction, 4.75-inch forefoot width, and heavy nubuck leather upper. The three top-most metal lacing hooks allowed us to get a secure and fine-tuned fit, especially as the leather began to break in. Weighing in at 2.77 pounds for a US size 11, these aren't the lightest boots in the lineup, but they also aren't the heaviest. However, we think the support and durability that come with these heavier materials are well worth the additional weight. Huetter said, “The five-millimeter lugs are spaced in a pattern that bites down into loose terrain, while the wide outer lugs increase surface area.” There aren't many places we wouldn't take this midweight and stable hiking boot, from light trails to backpacking treks. The boots are made waterproof by a Gore-Tex lining and five-inch flood height, which we found to be very effective as we braved river crossings and snow fields.
The Kaha's nubuck leather upper took a few hikes to break in, especially around the toe box where the foot flexes. We grew to appreciate the unique Swallowtail heel design, but when hiking off-trail, it takes a bit of getting used to as it effectively makes the boot longer and more prone to getting caught on things. Our lead tester said, “During my first few times wearing these, I had uneven heel contact.” Rest assured, this went away within a few hikes. Additionally, the cushiony and wide outsole isn't the most responsive for edging in technical terrain. The Kaha is a pricey boot, and while we think it has outstanding value, not everyone is looking to spend a lot on boots. If you aren't overly interested in the extra cushion, we think the Merrell Moab 3 Mid Waterproof is worth considering. They have a shorter break-in time and check all the boxes for the casual hiker. Plus, they are a fraction of the price. The Salomon Quest 4 Gore-Tex has a more traditional styling and cushion. The Quests are another high-scorer across the board but sacrifice weight in doing so. Overall, though, the Kaha 2 offers many amazing features and is recommended to any hiker looking for high ankle support and maximum comfort. As Huetter notes, “these boots will make you feel less tired and sore at the end of the day,” and that sounds pretty good if you love spending time hiking trails as much as we do.
The La Sportiva Ultra Raptor II Mid GTX is our favorite hiking boot for women. It earns top marks in almost all categories, making it one of the most balanced hikers ever tested. The boots weigh in at just 1.68 pounds for an EU 40 (roughly US size 9). The AirMesh upper is rugged, durable, and incredibly comfortable, with our head tester Trish Matheny saying it “delivered comfort right out of the box.” The five-inch shaft offers a surprising level of stability for its design, and it is fit to take on technical surfaces. It features a Gore-Tex waterproof membrane with a breathable design and a 4.25-inch flood height. The deep lugs do well on everything from rock slabs to sloppy steeps, making it a trustworthy and versatile option for most trails. Trish said she had “the confidence to rip through steep descents on loose and variable terrain” in these boots. They are an excellent option for any day trip or backpacking adventure.
While we appreciate the lightweight design of this trail runner-like hiking boot, it's not nearly as stable as other midweight boots that are made from leather, like the La Sportiva Nucleo High II GTX or Hoka Kaha 2 GTX. The Nucleo weighs more than the Ultra Raptor at 2.14 pounds but has excellent waterproofing. Similarly, the Hoka Kaha sacrifices weight for stability, but we found this boot to be just as comfortable and durable as the Ultra Raptor II. The Ultra Raptor also fits small, so we recommend sizing up. However, these boots can still withstand various weather and are suited for long backpacking adventures and day trips. When all is said and done, it truly shines as a protective and lightweight hiking boot that sacrifices some stability.
Looking to get out on the trails but not excited about a premium price tag? The Merrell Moab 3 Mid Waterproof is a great deal that'll get you out on the trails in most conditions. This waterproof leather and mesh boot is incredibly comfortable, and the break-in period is almost non-existent. Within 10 miles, we felt like these boots were comfortably broken in. The boot features a nylon arch support and Super Rebound Compound midsole, functioning much like EVA and molding to the foot overtime. It's an excellent option for beginners and experts alike who are looking for a boot that delivers great performance at a decent value. Tester Ryan Huetter says “It is a perfect introductory boot for someone new to hiking but also can offer something for the seasoned adventurer.” The boots kept our feet fairly dry during testing with their four-inch flood height and Pigskin exterior.
Despite our appreciation of the comfort and performance, this boot comes with a few limitations. For instance, the design is on the heavier side at 2.44 pounds for a US size 11. Furthermore, the Vibram TC5+ sole sticks well to dry and technical surfaces, but the lugs lack the appropriate spacing between them to shed mud easily. They perform poorly in super muddy or sloppy conditions for this reason. The Asolo Fugitive GTX had excellent traction, even in loose skree and mud. They also have half an inch more of flood height and withstood our submersion tests with no trouble. However, these enhanced features will cost you in weight and cash. If you want to save even more money, check out the Timberland Mt. Maddsen Mid Waterproof. It was not nearly as comfortable as the Moab 3, but they are slightly lighter and more durable than the Moab . Nevertheless, the Merrell Moab 3 boot is a high-value option that'll keep you comfortable and protected for most outdoor adventures, and in the words of Ryan Huetter, “You get a lot of boot for a fair price.”
Lacks support for long hikes and backpacking trips
Lacing system has questionable durability
Heavy
SPECIFICATIONS
Upper
Leather, mesh
Measured Weight (per pair)
2.06 lbs (size 8)
Width Options
Regular, wide
Waterproof Lining
Waterproof membrane
Midsole
Super Rebound Compound
The Merrell Moab 3 Mid WP offers excellent value. It is designed as a day hiker and moderate backpacking boot so that it can go with you on most adventures. It features a comfortable and easy-to-break-in design and generous padding in the ankle shaft. Tester Trish Matheny mentions that “The extra room in the toe box makes these boots a great choice for those with wider feet,” and if you need something even roomier, it comes in a wide version as well. It has excellent durability, with several mesh panels between the leather infrastructure that held up during our most rugged hikes. The new and improved Vibram sole offers sufficient traction on most trail surfaces, making it a great, high-value option for most adventures. These withstood the chilly river crossings, thanks to its waterproof design and four-inch flood height.
We love the comfort and value this boot offers. What we don't love is the lacing system, which lacks durability. The boot also weighs more than much of the competition at 2.06 pounds for a US size 8. Our lightest boot, the Altra Lone Peak ALL-WTHR Mid 2 was more than half a pound lighter at 1.48 pounds. The Lone Peaks were one of the most comfortable boots we tested, but fell short in traction compared to the Moab. The Merrell Moab still wasn't our best boot for traction. Though it did well on most surfaces, it struggled in muddy conditions.The Salomon X Ultra 4 Mid Gore-Tex's traction does well across all surfaces and is often on sale for prices near or below the Moab 3. That said, the Moab 3 Mid WP functions well for most adventures, including backpacking, while putting a smaller dent in your wallet than most hiking boots, and according to Trish, the “comfort and extra cushion in the new design exceed the expectations of the modest price tag.”
The Moab 3 Mid WP offers excellent comfort for day hikes and other quick treks. We tested the waterproofing extensively and were impressed with how well they kept out water.
Functional ankle cuff without a ton of bulky padding
Waterproof
REASONS TO AVOID
Sizing runs small
Durability concerns
SPECIFICATIONS
Upper
Leather, mesh and webbing
Measured Weight (per pair)
1.80 lbs (size 8.5)
Width Options
Regular, wide
Waterproof Lining
Omni-Tech
Midsole
TechLite
The Columbia Crestwood Mid is a lightweight and affordable hiking boot that offers impressive performance, especially when considering its modest price tag. Our lead tester Trish Matheny, who has a narrow foot and high arch, says this boot was “comfortable immediately out of the box”. However, it caters mostly to those with a narrow foot shape as the sizing runs a bit small. The boot is also available in a wide fit for those who might benefit from more space in the toe box. Our testers appreciated the functional ankle cuff, which offers the perfect amount of padding to add comfort without preventing breathability. The upper is also primarily constructed from mesh, along with leather and webbing, and remained fully waterproof during our testing period. Whether we were moving through snow or crossing streams, the Omni-Tech coating released any moisture we encountered, as it simply beaded off the waterproof upper. Trish also noted that “the mesh upper also kept our feet cool and comfortable during the hottest days of testing,” thanks to a design that is not overly padded, and the mesh inlays that aid in overall breathability.
Though our testing team was impressed with this affordable boot, we do have a few concerns. We found the Omni-Grip outsole to perform exceptionally well on slippery rocks and boulders, but the lug pattern simply wasn't deep enough to grip when hiking through loose terrain like sand. We also have durability concerns with the mesh attachments on the lacing system. Our testers found that reversing the final lace in the system near the ankle cuff allowed us to tighten the boot without applying as much force to the mesh attachment. We're hopeful this tip will prolong the life of your hiking boots. And though we didn't experience any durability issues within our spring testing period, we couldn't help but wonder about the longevity of this design. While we appreciate the breathability and comfort offered by the primarily mesh upper, it simply may not last as long as its counterparts that feature a fully leather design. If durability is a concern, the budget-friendly Merrell Moab is slightly more equipped in that respect, though still not the most burly in the lineup. Those concerns aside, we are confident in recommending the Columbia Crestwood, and our testers liked the “lightweight sneaker-like feel underfoot” for day hikes and backcountry overnights on well-maintained trail systems. The Crestwoods did an excellent job during our water resistance assessment, but if you're looking for a boot that offers even better protection while battling the elements, the Hoka Anacapa 2 Mid GTX is one of the best at repelling water.
The Salomon Quest 4 Gore-Tex is a high-top boot that offers a ton of over-the-ankle support for backpacking trips and for long adventures on the most technical and demanding trails. Our lead men's tester, Ryan Huetter, loves how comfortable the Salomon is, saying, “this boot is such a treat to slip into.” The EnergyCell midsole is responsive enough to take impacts, further adding to the overall comfort. When the ankle collar is fully laced, these boots provide an excellent amount of stability. Ryan noted that he “felt more protected while wearing this boot than nearly any other model in challenging terrain.” The beefy, spaced out lugs bite down on all surfaces, offering traction on slippery, steep trails and rocky river crossings. These boots have an impressive 5.5-inch tall flood height, and didn't leak when we submerged them during our tests. If you're in the market for a well-rounded boot that'll offer comfort and stability while shouldering a heavy pack, this top contender is the way to go.
We found the Quest 4 protective and stable but also heavy for a hiker, weighing in at 3.27 pounds for a size 11. Moreover, it does not breathe or release heat as readily as we want. Though this boot can function as a casual daily hiker, it thrives on technical surfaces and tricky conditions. Want a lighter option? The Hoka Kaha 2 GTX scored slightly higher and is lighter, though it's not as adept at off-trail travel. And while we love the comfort of the Quest 4, it took a few hikes before the boots felt broken in. This additional break-in period is to be expected from a heavyweight boot with a leather upper, though it is worth noting they might not feel the best right out of the box, like the Moab. However, if you tend towards gnarly trails and long excursions, we feel that the Salomon Quest is a terrific choice for folks wanting a high-performance boot, with our tester saying that it is an “easy choice to single out as the best boot to wear on demanding hikes with heavy loads.”
The Quest boots take a little while to lace up. However, once you tie the laces, you feel the ankle support and height that keeps out most debris and water. We even measured these boots flood height to be a whopping 5.5 inches.
The Hoka Kaha 2 GTX offers superior comfort, with two inches of foam stacked into its midsole. It is one of the thickest models we have tested, easily providing a smooth landing surface every time.The five millimeter lugs and sticky Vibram Megagrip rubber hold well on tricky surfaces; tester Trish Matheny says they provide “killer traction through variable terrain.” They also offer a surprising amount of water protection, and the reinforced nubuck leather upper resists scuffs and scratches. The tongue has extra padding, which helps to protect against the supportive lacing system. The lacing system also allows for a wide variety of foot types. The toe box is wider than the closely related Hoka Anacapa 2 Mid GTX, but the three metal lacing hooks allow for a more precise fit, even for narrower feet. Hands down, this boot offers the best cushioning on the market. Check it out if comfort is your top priority.
The thick cushioning underfoot is heavenly, but getting used to it may require an adjustment period. We had to train ourselves to lift our feet just slightly to avoid unsuspected trips when hiking over rocky terrain in the Kaha 2. And though the leather upper offers superior waterproofing, it lacks breathability. In our testing, all the most comfortable boots typically cost the most. The exception was the Keen Targhee IV Mid, which was very comfy and about half the price. It scored lower in most metrics than the Kaha but gives solid comfort and has a more traditional sole and styling. Still, if ample cushioning and excellent underfoot protection are your main priority, the Hoka Kaha is our recommendation. After lacing up these boots, testers said, “We were confident to take on the burliest of backcountry missions.”
The La Sportiva Ultra Raptor II Mid GTX is comfortable and agile like a trail running shoe but rugged and capable like a proper boot. If you want to be able to handle all terrain types, this lightweight boot is one to seriously consider. The boot has a 6.75-inch comfort collar, and when paired with the lacing system, it makes for a sturdy fit over the ankle. These boots weigh in at 2.08 pounds for an EU 45. Though this isn't the lightest boot in the lineup, they are fairly light for the features they include, like the tall collar. The five-inch flood height also kept our feet dry when walking through river crossings. From walking on mellow trails to navigating cross-country obstacles, the Raptor is ready to tackle and transition. “If cross-country and off-trail hiking is your thing,” our lead tester says, then “you will love this boot.”
Besides the steep price, our only real gripe about the Ultra Raptor II Mid is that it runs small — we ordered up a half size for a proper fit. You may want to try these on in person or at least order from a retailer with a good return policy. The Raptor is also available in wide sizes, which we appreciate since the regular version — like many La Sportiva shoes — is on the narrow side. After testing these for a few years, we have some concerns on their longevity. In heavy use, you might only get a couple of years of use out of them before they begin breaking down. If you desire more traction and durability and don't mind the extra weight, check out the Scarpa Zodiac Plus GTX. If you want to do it all and have your feet be happy and nimble the entire time, check out the La Sportiva Ultra Raptor, which our tester calls “a machine built for a steady diet of off-trail travel.”
Our hiking experts agree that the Altra Lone Peak ALL-WTHR Mid 2 is a fantastic option for wide feet. It features a durable lacing system, thicker cushioning underfoot, and traction that performs in wet and dry weather. It's a favorite for wide feet because it has a unique toe box that allows your toes to splay and wiggle freely while hiking. It offers the fit and flexibility of a running shoe but with a little more support to shoulder a heavy pack. These weigh in at just 1.48 pounds for a size 8.5, which was the lightest in our women's lineup. Trish Matheny, lead tester for our women's review, appreciates the lightweight nature of the boot, saying from experience that “you'll be grateful to leave the extra weight and added fatigue of a traditional hiking boot behind.”
The Altra ALL-WTHR is lightweight but not nearly as durable as some leather hiking boots. If you want comfort and durability, check out the Hoka Kaha 2 GTX which features a nubuck leather upper. However, we've tested the Altras over multiple seasons and have been pleasantly surprised with how well they've held up. Though we don't recommend wearing microspikes with these boots, as the lightweight nature of them allows them to scrunch up. Another thing to note is that the zero-drop design also requires an adjustment period if you aren't already used to it. If your top priority is a wide fit, comfortable design, and excellent cushioning underfoot, we think you'll be happy with this pick. The Keen Targhee IV is another wide option that does not have a zero-drop. Trish is a fan, saying, “Whether you're stoked to push your pace on the trails or simply take in the beauty of nature, we're confident that this boot won't let you down”. It's a favorite amongst thru-hikers and fast packers, where comfort and weight are imperative considerations. And, we are also more than happy to grab these for a quick hike.
If you live in a wet climate or prefer a steep hike to dry conditions, consider the La Sportiva Nucleo High II GTX. This waterproof boot beats out the competition in terms of performance in wet conditions. We tested it by hiking in the rain and trudging through rivers. Stream crossings were “absolutely no problem”, our tester Ben Applebaum-Bauch reported. The gusseted tongue, Gore-Tex Surround membrane, and nubuck leather construction do well to keep water out, keeping our socks dry time and time again. The Nucleo also offers a superior level of comfort, and our tester also noted that the “side-to-side support is still excellent.” The deep lugs are sticky, holding well on sloppy and dry surfaces. Despite these heavyweight features, it is a relatively light boot, and Ben says, “it punches above its weight class.” It is a great option for all types of adventures in wet (or dry) conditions.
That said, we wish this boot offered more stability, like the La Sportiva Trango Tech GTX, another solid option for water resistance. This boot is blend between hiker, approach, and mountaineering boot, so it exceeds in support in traction. However, it isn't as friendly for day hikes, and they are pricey. The upper cuff on the Nucleo High II around the ankle is not very rigid, which translates to less stability on uneven surfaces. Additionally, inserting the lace into the boot's eyelets isn't easy, meaning it takes longer to lace up and release. However, if you're seeking a bombproof boot for water or snow, this is the one you should check out. The La Sportiva Trango Tech GTX also exceeds in its waterproofing ability and has superb traction; however, it isn't as lightweight as the Nucleo.
The La Sportiva Nucleo High II GTX is our top choice for wet conditions. If you find yourself in snow, rain, or crossing a lot of streams, this is the boot to consider.
For ladies seeking a hiking boot that does well in wet environments, the Nucleo High II GTX features some of the best waterproofing on the market, and lead tester Trish Matheny says “its waterproof protection is truly what sets this boot apart from the rest.” Built with a nubuck leather exterior, Gore-Tex waterproof ventilation, and a gusseted tongue, it has proven to keep feet dry in the wettest conditions. The construction is incredibly durable, showing little wear and tear after our testing period. It offers a comfortable fit and a short break-in period. It's a wonderful option for any adventure in wet (or dry) conditions.
While this boot is waterproof, it's not very breathable. In addition, its waterproofing elements make it heavier than other lightweight options on the market at 2.14 pounds for an EU 40. We recommend the La Sportiva Nucleo High II GTX if your primary interest is withstanding wet conditions. Around the same weight, the Danner Mountain 600 Leaf Gore-Tex is another solid waterproof option. These feature 4.5 inches of flood height and kept our feet dry during our submersion tests, though we found the Nucleo to be slightly more durable. Additionally, the Nucleo is a pricey boot. However, If a waterproof, supportive, and rugged hiker is what you're after, Trish says you can “consider the Nucleo a solid investment.”
While not a true winter boot, the Nucleo keeps out water and is high enough to keep out snow in most situations. It is a great option for warmer winter weather where you still want dexterity and don't want the clunkiness of a traditional winter boot.
Credit: Trish Matheny
How We Test Hiking Boots
Since 2012, we've researched and tested over 145 unique pairs of hiking boots for women and men. We purchase all products directly from the retailer to provide an unbiased review. After they arrive on our doorstep, we do the dirty work, breaking in each pair and taking to the trail. Our testers wore these boots for thousands of collective miles, with over 500 hours of field time while hiking, camping, fishing, rock climbing, and backpacking through many different conditions. We spent time in all kinds of weather, from hot, sunny days to snow storms to heavy downpours. During this testing period, our team kept detailed notes about the performance of each boot after each hike and after completing a series of objective tests. Award winners were carefully determined after gathering data and after many hours of consideration. We tested women's hiking boots and men's hiking boots, with a focus on lightweight and midweight designs, suitable for all seasons.
The hiking boots we tested were considered across 6 key test metrics including:
Comfort
Support
Traction
Water Resistance
Weight
Durability
We tested the flood height to see at what point water soaks in.
The intricate design of the Rush 2's PRESA SuperGum rubber outsole. Note the different tread patterns for optimized grip and the braking system for secure footing.
The 1.8 pound pair of US Women's size 8.5 scores below average on our average weight calculation, in addition to offering a lightweight feel.
For hundreds of miles and over all kinds of terrain, we've put the boots in our reviews through the wringer.
Why Trust GearLab
Our team of experts has spent countless days trekking around the world, over all types of terrain, in all sorts of weather, all in the name of testing the best hiking boots on the market. Tag-teaming the men's hiking boot review are professional guides Ryan Huetter and Ben Applebaum-Bauch. Ryan is an AMGA/IFMGA certified mountain guide with a bachelor's degree in outdoor adventure management. He has been guiding trips around the U.S. for a decade and uses hiking boots near-daily for work and play. Ben has led groups on backpacking, cycling, and canoeing tours through much of New England's wilderness. When not guiding, he has embarked on many extended self-supported adventures through the same territory. Both are avid hikers who love long trails and use hiking boots for everything from short day hikes to extended thru-hikes in places across the U.S. and into South America. Our current boot lineup was tested in locations like the Pacific Crest Trail and Colorado Trail.
Lead testers for our women's hiking boot review are Jane Jackson and Trish Matheny. Jane is a professional mountain guide with experience working in places like the Tetons, Yosemite, and Alaska. On top of that, Jane has put hundreds of miles in her boots, hiking for pleasure in beautiful places ranging from the high altitudes of the Himalayas to the long trails circumnavigating the granite mountains in the Western United States. Trish has spent much of the last 15 years in the backcountry. She has worked and played on dusty, muddy, and rocky trails across the United States, all with a pair of hiking boots strapped to her feet. Collectively, they've logged hundreds of hours of trail time, testing in all manner of terrain to see how each boot performed.
We tested hiking boots off-trail in the High Sierra. We have found no better test for support and traction than navigating talus fields with a pack on.
Credit: Ryan Huetter
How to Pick the Best Hiking Boots for You
Hiking boots are best for adventurers seeking footwear that offers protection and stability on the trail. With such a wide variety of options on the market, searching for a pair that will best suit your needs seems daunting. With our experience, we can help you find exactly what you're looking for. To begin, there are various factors to consider when choosing the best boot for you, including how you will use the boot, the type of boot you need, its fit and design, and how long the break-in period may last. Taking these considerations to heart will help steer you in the right direction to finding your best boot for hiking. Let's dive in.
Men's Hiking Boots
We have tested many pairs of men's boots on the market and discuss them more in-depth in our men's hiking boots review. Below is a chart displaying these boots and how they scored compared to each other.
Key Metric Scores - Men's Hiking Boots
Product
Comfort
Support
Traction
Water Resistance
Hoka Kaha 2
9
9
8
8
Scarpa Zodiac Plus
7
9
10
8
Salomon Quest 4
9
9
8
8
La Sportiva Trango Tech
6
9
10
8
La Sportiva Ultra Raptor II
7
8
9
7
La Sportiva Nucleo High II
6
7
8
9
Lowa Renegade
7
8
7
8
Salomon X Ultra 4
8
7
8
7
Hoka Anacapa 2
7
7
8
8
Arc\'teryx Acrux TR
6
8
8
7
Merrell Moab 3 Mid WP
8
7
6
7
Altra Lone Peak ALL-WTHR 2
9
6
5
7
Timberland Mt. Maddsen
4
8
7
8
Keen Targhee III
7
6
7
6
Keen Zionic
7
5
6
5
Timberland White Ledge
4
5
6
5
Columbia Newton Ridge Plus II
4
5
6
4
Women's Hiking Boots
Our full review of women's hiking boots dives deep into the best models available today. Below, we show the four most important metrics we used to test them, as well as their scores.
Key Metric Scores - Women's Hiking Boots
Product
Comfort
Support
Traction
Water Resistance
La Sportiva Ultra Raptor II
9
8
9
8
Hoka Kaha 2 GTX
9
9
8
8
La Sportiva Nucleo High II
8
8
8
9
Danner Mountain 600 Leaf
8
8
8
8.5
Salomon X Ultra 4
7
8
9
8
Hoka Anacapa 2
8
8
7
9
Teva Grandview
9
7
8
7
Lowa Renegade
7
8
8
8
Salomon Quest 4
7
8
8
8
Scarpa Rush 2
8
6.5
8
8
Altra Lone Peak ALL-WTHR 2
9
7
6
8
Merrell Moab 3 WP
7
7.5
8
7.5
Columbia Crestwood
7
7.5
7
8
Oboz Bridger
6
7
8
8
Salomon Outpulse
8
6
7
7
Keen Zionic
8
5
7
8
Keen Targhee III
7
5
7
8
Salewa Alpenrose 2
6
4
8
7
Keen Targhee IV
6
6
5
7.5
NORTIV 8 WP
5
3
7.5
8.5
Danner Mountain 600
5
4
6
7
Columbia Newton Ridge
6
4
5
6
Hiking Boot Components
Understanding the components and materials used in hiking boots can help you on your way to finding the best pair for you. The main components of a hiking boot include the upper, midsole, outsole, and waterproofing agent. Various materials exist within each of these components, so read on to figure out which are important to you.
Hiking Boot Components
Upper
Midsole
Outsole
Waterproofing
Hoka Kaha 2
Nubuck leather
Rubberized EVA
Vibram Megagrip
Gore-Tex
Merrell Moab 3 Mid Waterproof
Leather, mesh
EVA: Super Rebound Compound
Vibram TC5+
Non-specific waterproofing
Salomon Quest 4 Gore-Tex
Leather, nylon
EnergyCell
Rubber: Contragrip
Gore-Tex
La Sportiva Ultra Raptor II Mid
AirMesh, microfiber, TPU
Nylon molded flex TPU
Frixion XF 2.0
Gore-Tex
La Sportiva Nucleo High II GTX
Nubuck Leather
Compression molded EVA
Vibram Nano XS-Trek
Gore-Tex Surround
Altra Lone Peak ALL-WTHR 2
eVent fabric
Altra Ego
Rubber: MaxTrak
Water resistant bootie
Columbia Crestwood
Leather, mesh, webbing
TechLite
Omni-Grip
Omni-Tech
Upper
The upper refers to the portion of material that covers the sides and top of your foot. These materials can be broken down into leather or synthetic materials. However, many boots use a combination of both.
Leather: Boots made with leather are going to have some of the best durability, but will lack breathability and flexibility from synthetic materials. That in mind, leather boots often take longer to break in. Full grain and nubuck leather will resist water and scrapes better than synthetic materials like nylon or polyester.
Synthetics: There are many synthetic materials used to create uppers, like nylon and polyester. These materials tend to be less durable than leather but offer a quicker break-in period. When treated, they can be waterproof, and even if not, they often dry quicker than leather.
Made from nubuck leather, the Kaha 2 is one of the most durable boots in our lineup.
Credit: Trish Matheny
Midsole
The midsole is a layer of foam or soft plastic, usually made from EVA or PU, between the insole and outsole. If you remove the insole, the material directly underneath is the midsole. This is where most cushion and support are within the shoe.
EVA: Ethylene vinyl acetate (EVA) is very commonly used for shoe and boot midsoles. This lightweight material is made from very tiny air bubbles inside the foam. Over time, EVA will mold to your foot, but it can wear down quicker than PU. EVA is more commonly used in light to midweight boots, but because EVA has different densities, you might also see it in more aggressive boots.
PU: Polyurethane (PU) is a synthetic plastic commonly found in heavyweight and backpacking boots. It doesn't break down easily and will not form to your foot. The benefit of this is longevity and stability.
The Moab 3 presents excellent value with functionality extending from day hikes to moderate backpacking adventures.
Credit: Trinity Robinson
Outsole
The outsole is the bottom portion of the boot that you walk on. Outsole material and lug shape are very important for traction. Though all outsoles are made from rubber, some specific blends exist, like Vibram, which are used by many manufacturers.
Waterproofing
Most hiking boots in this review are waterproof, but are also available in non-waterproof versions too. The most popular waterproofing materials are Gore-Tex and eVent. Both of these membranes aim to prevent water droplets from entering, but allows for water vapor to escape. As a result, your feet stay dry from the elements and sweat.
Manufacturer-Specific Materials: Some manufacturers have their own line of materials. Though these might have fancy names, they are often still using the same or similar materials like EVA or PU.
The La Sportiva Ultra Raptor II has a Gore-Tex membrane that keeps your feet dry.
Credit: Trish Matheny
Types of Hiking Boots
We've been discussing several different types of hiking boots, so let's take the time to define each. In this section, we'll cover lightweight, midweight, and heavyweight hikers. In addition, we'll discuss hiking shoes and trail runners, as these are common substitutes.
Hiking Boot Type
Boot Type
Best Uses
Altra Lone Peak ALL-WTHR 2
Lightweight
Day hikes
Columbia Crestwood
Lightweight
Day hikes
La Sportiva Ultra Raptor II Mid
Lightweight
Day hikes, backpacking, light technical terrain
Hoka Kaha 2
Midweight
Day hikes, backpacking
Merrell Moab 3 Mid Waterproof
Midweight
Day hikes, backpacking
La Sportiva Nucleo High II GTX
Midweight
Day hikes, backpacking, light technical terrain
Salomon Quest 4 Gore-Tex
Heavyweight
Day hikes, backpacking, light technical terrain
Lightweight Hikers
Lightweight hiking boots typically have a low to mid-cut, not rising more than four or five inches, and are constructed with more flexible fabrics. These designs have often done away with stability elements, such as rigid shanks embedded in the midsole. They also tend to have more flexible cuffs around the ankle, so there's not as much ankle support as you might encounter with a midweight or heavyweight hiking boot. This boot category is best for those who prefer light feet on the trail or easy-to-moderate trails that aren't technical.
A couple examples of lightweight boot construction. Note the amount of mesh, and the thinner midsole.
Credit: Ryan Huetter
Midweight Hikers
A traditional hiker is a midweight hiking boot. Typically weighing two to three pounds per pair, they rise four to five inches on the ankle. They are usually more rigid than a lightweight hiker but more flexible than a heavyweight boot. They offer better stability and durability than most lightweight hiking boots tested.
Designed for versatility, this type of boot is a great option for day hikes and backpacking. They are built to handle 20 to 30-pound backpacks across rugged terrain. They feature stiff soles, leather construction, an ankle cuff that fits well, and stability elements. Most feature breathable vents that don't allow particulates to get inside. If stability is a higher priority than weight, this is a good type of boot for all outdoor adventures.
A midweight hiker is a fantastic choice if you seek ankle support with lightweight construction.
The budget-friendly Moab 3 Mid is a perfect example of a mid weight hiking boot. Stable and supportive, yet flexible and comfortable.
Credit: Ryan Huetter
Heavyweight Hikers
These burly hikers are heavy, full-leather hiking boots designed for off-trail explorations and mountaineering adventures. They are designed to carry a 40+ pound backpack across treacherous terrain and often weigh upwards of three pounds per pair. During this review, we didn't feature any heavyweight boots, but there are many options on the market, and our lineup has some that lean in that direction. They are typically completely waterproof, extremely durable, and very heavy. They are built with full-grain leather and TPU midsoles, with several stability elements. They are designed to handle the roughest terrain and the most extreme conditions.
Places where a heavier hiking boot might be useful include while carrying a heavy load, or locations where stiffness and support are a priority.
Credit: Ryan Huetter
Hiking Shoes
So what's the difference between a hiking shoe and a hiking boot? The biggest difference is ankle stability. Hiking shoes do not have high cuff ankle support, whereas a hiking boot will. Many of the design elements—including stability, waterproofing, and traction—can be the same. Hiking shoes are also typically quite durable, with better breathability and lower weight than most hiking boots. These are a great option if you don't care too much about ankle support but still want a supportive and stable shoe for exploring the outdoors.
A hiking shoe is a great alternative to a hiking boot. They offer excellent stability and durability, just without the extra ankle support.
Credit: Myrha Colt
Trail Runners
If you want to go fast and light and aren't in need of as much stability and support, a trail runner is a good option to consider. Trail running shoes vary widely in their design, but many of them offer similar stability elements at a lighter weight and with more breathable and flexible upper materials. Although they are at the bottom of the pack when it comes to support, it really comes down to user preference, and you can even find some trail runners that are nearly on par with light hiking shoes. If you don't need ankle coverage, and weight is paramount in your choice of shoe, then you should look at our trail running shoe review to scope out the different options on the market.
These trail runners are perfect for those considering fast and light missions in the backcountry.
Credit: Ally Arcuri
Where Do You Hike?
Now that we have covered the materials used and the different types of boot, we can now take a look at the best style for your future trails. If you mostly do day hikes, a heavyweight boot likely isn't necessary. Though if you prefer to tackle rugged terrain, you might opt for a more aggressive boot. The boot you choose will also depend on your climate and whether waterproofing is necessary.
Day Hikes
When you're heading out for a day hike, the type of footwear you choose depends on the intensity of the hike, how technical it is, and how much weight you carry. Sometimes, a lightweight hiking boot with minimal ankle support may be all you need. The lighter materials used in lightweight boots make them more flexible and breathable. They also have enough comfort and support to carry substantial loads. Most offer more stability than hiking shoes or trail runners, but they aren't as heavy as midweight hiking boots. Consider a midweight boot, even for day hikes, if you prefer more stability.
One of our testers heads out into the backcountry on a long day trip with a small, but heavier pack in tow.
Credit: Trish Matheny
Backpacking and Rugged Terrain
Backpacking all your gear into a campsite for the night can be strenuous, but it can also be made easier by footwear with a little more stability, especially around the ankle. For any moderate backpacking adventure, a midweight boot is recommended. This type of boot has stability on unstable surfaces without being too heavy. This is helpful when shouldering a heavy pack for a couple of days. A lightweight boot can also function for moderate backpacking adventures. However, with larger loads, your feet might get a little more beat up than they would in a more rigid midweight boot.
Hiking boots considered for backpacking objectives should provide ample ankle support along with effective support through the midsole.
Credit: Trish Matheny
Warm and Dry Climates
If you mostly hike in a dry climate, opting for a waterproof boot might not be the best choice. Even though modern waterproofing allows sweat to escape, it isn't as breathable as non-waterproofed boots. Some of the boots we have tested are available in both waterproof and non-waterproof options. So if you aren't worried about snow or runoff on your hiking trails, you might opt for one of these options.
Waterproofing Availability
Waterproof Option
Non-Waterproof Option
Altra Lone Peak ALL-WTHR 2
Columbia Crestwood
✖
La Sportiva Ultra Raptor II Mid
✖
Hoka Kaha 2
✖
Merrell Moab 3 Mid Waterproof
La Sportiva Nucleo High II GTX
✖
Salomon Quest 4 Gore-Tex
✖
Wet Climates
Many people opt for hiking boots instead of hiking shoes because they have some level of water resistance or waterproofing. If you find yourself hiking in wet weather, look for a boot that integrates a seamless design, waterproof or Gore-Tex membrane, and leather construction. An extra plus is a gusseted tongue, which will protect you better during river crossings.
Planning a hike in a precipitous part of the country or with multiple creek crossings? The La Sportiva Nucleo is a top choice for waterproof protection for its ability to repel water.
Credit: Steve Mace
Additional Factors to Consider
You need to consider the length of time you'll be wearing your boots, and also the conditions. This includes the trail's climate, temperature, surfaces, and steepness. A lightweight hiking boot should be fine if you prefer easy hikes on flat terrain. But, if you often take on steep and technical trails with talus fields, consider a more stable design.
Traction
You'll encounter many different surfaces when you're out on the trail. Wet, dry, steep, and flat — they will vary. For example, kitty litter gravel over rock in dry conditions can cause unsuspected slips when the trails are steep. Steep slabs can also be treacherous, especially if a boot can't grip the rock. A soft, sticky rubber with evenly spaced lugs is preferred.
If you encounter wet conditions, like slippery rocks, mud, ice, or snow, you'll want to look for a combination of deeper lugs that are well-spaced and a sticky rubber that doesn't get too hard in colder temperatures. The spacing of the lugs will help shed mud and snow more easily. The deeper lugs will help bite down on the trail, especially when traveling up or downhill. Regardless of the specific conditions, think about the surfaces you'll be hiking on and then look at the design and construction of the outsole to ensure it'll do what you need it to on your adventures.
A sticky rubber sole provides great traction for loose kitty litter that is found abundantly in the Sierra Nevada.
Credit: Alexa Flower
Breathability
A boot that can breathe is important, especially in hot or humid weather. Without breathability, a hiking boot can turn a dry sock into a wet one, which is a great way to end up with hot spots or full-on blisters. While considering your options, look for breathable panels protecting from small particulates. If hiking in warmer conditions, look for a light design. A hiking shoe or trail running shoe is also a nice alternative for a hiking boot in hot weather, as long as you're okay with less stability through the ankle and body of the boot.
Full leather uppers are not nearly as breathable as those constructed from mesh and synthetic materials, although leather designs are typically more durable.
Credit: Trish Matheny
Weight
A lighter boot is the most common preference for most people when hiking. Who doesn't like to feel light? It means you can go further, and the hike always seems much more enjoyable. We recommend looking for a pair of less than four-pound boots. Anything heavier will seem strenuous to hike in, especially if you intend to go out for the day. When you're doing your research on different products, be sure to check out the weight specs to see how each boot measures up.
The Rush 2's lightweight design doesn't compromise on performance.
Credit: Trish Matheny
Fit and Sizing
No matter how high the ratings and how great the features are, if the boot doesn't fit, it's not the right boot for you. You can premeditate all of the features you want, but until you slip it on and try it out, you won't know if it's the right one for you.
Getting the right size is key. A shoe that isn't the right size can cause hot spots and blisters. Ouch!
Credit: Trish Matheny
Before trying on a boot, grab a sock of similar thickness that you intend to hike in. This will impact the overall fit. When you slide your foot inside and lace it up, note the additional volume or wiggle room in the toe box. Notice if your toes feel cramped front to back or side to side. If they do, you might need to size up a half size or find a different brand that is either wider or more narrow. Walk around and test out the flexibility and stability of the boot. Point your toes, go up the stairs, and walk around on unstable surfaces to see how the boot flexes or if there are any pinch points. If you require specific support, consider using insoles. Once you've found a fit that works, start getting excited because you're on your way to buying your perfect boot.
If you're ordering online, select a retailer with a good return policy so you can return anything that isn't a good fit.
Stable as a table! The Merrell Moab 3 does well to provide the user with a secure and supportive fit.
Credit: Ryan Huetter
Break-In Period
After you've found your pair of hiking boots, know that they will most likely require a break-in period. Depending on the construction and materials, break-in times vary. Lightweight hikers with softer materials typically have a faster break-in period than those with more rigid materials. Midweight hikers have the widest range of time since there are so many combinations of materials in the construction. Some, for example, might take longer to break in than those with a different type of leather.
Finally, test your boots on short hikes before committing to longer adventures. The boots need time to mold and shape. Even in the “right” boot, diving straight into a long, grueling hike can still lead to blisters or other issues on the trail, something nobody wants.
The Scarpa Zodiacs are the perfect hiking boots for any terrain, from desert trails to mountaintops.
Credit: Ryan Huetter
Conclusion
Choosing the right pair of hiking footwear is the single most important choice you have to make before hitting the trails. Whether you are planning an epic long-distance hike, or just hitting the local trail system, you need to have footwear that is right for the job. Trail runners and hiking shoes might cut it, but for the ultimate in comfort and support you want a great pair of hiking boots. We hiked for miles and miles to check out some of the many models available so you don't have to, ensuring that no matter what kind of hike you want to get out on, that we can recommend a pair that will work for you.
If you're seeking hiking socks to compliment your boots, we've got your feet covered. When your day on the trail is done and you're looking to slip into something more comfortable, check out our advice on cozy slippers. Happy trails!
—
Trish Matheny, Ryan Huetter, Jane Jackson, and Ben Applebaum-Bauch
