Mammut Haldigrat HS Bib Review
Our Verdict
Compare to Similar Products
This Product
Mammut Haldigrat HS Bib | |||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|
Awards | Best Overall Bib Pant | Best Overall Ski Pants | Best for Backcountry | Best Bang for the Buck | Best Bargain for Bibs |
Price | $499.00 at Backcountry Compare at 2 sellers | $480.00 at Evo Compare at 2 sellers | $186.71 at Amazon Compare at 3 sellers | $109.73 at REI Compare at 4 sellers | $198.95 at Backcountry Compare at 5 sellers |
Overall Score | |||||
Star Rating | |||||
Bottom Line | The best bibs out there, these pants are comfortable and protective | Excellent ski pants in every regard, and you'll pay for it | Comfortable, flexible pants for ski touring and sunny days at the resort | Plenty of performance for a low price | Decent ski bibs for an excellent price |
Rating Categories | Mammut Haldigrat HS... | Arc'teryx Sabre Pant | Outdoor Research Tr... | Helly Hansen Legend... | The North Face Free... |
Weather Resistance (25%) | |||||
Fit and Comfort (25%) | |||||
Ventilation (20%) | |||||
Warmth (10%) | |||||
Features (10%) | |||||
Style (10%) | |||||
Specs | Mammut Haldigrat HS... | Arc'teryx Sabre Pant | Outdoor Research Tr... | Helly Hansen Legend... | The North Face Free... |
Main fabric | Polyamide | Nylon | Nylon/Polyester/Spandex | Polyester | Recycled Nylon |
Insulation | None | None | None | Polyester | Recycled polyester |
Waterproofing | Drytech Pro | Gore-Tex | Ventia 3L Lower Legs | Helly Tech | DryVent 2L |
Waistline construction | Bibs | Integrated belt | Snap/zipper fly with adjustable tabs | Snap/zipper fly with adjustable tabs | Bibs |
Weight (in pounds) | 1.34 lbs | 1.28 lbs | 1.64 lbs | 1.30 lbs | 1.52 lbs |
Weight (in grams) | 608 g | 581 g | 744 g | 590 g | 689 g |
# of Pockets | 3 | 2 | 5 | 3 | 5 |
Vents | Outer thigh zips | Outer thigh zips | Outer thigh zips | Inner thigh zips | Inner thigh zips |
Ski-specific features | Transceiver pocket, cell phone slot, elastic gaiters, scuff guards | Scuff guards, transceiver pocket, elastic gaiters, integrated belt | Elastic cuffs, scuff guard, transceiver pocket, gussetted ankle zipper | Elastic Cuffs, Scuff Guards | Elastic cuffs, scuff guards |
Recco | No | Yes | No | No | No |
Our Analysis and Test Results
These bibs are unique for their snug fit around the torso, which provides a comfortable fit with a better range of motion than other bibs since there's less extra baggy material in the torso.
Performance Comparison
Weather Resistance
Bibs are made to keep out snow, wind, rain, and everything else that winter weather throws at you. The Mammut Haldigrat HS does a great job at keeping the user protected, with taped seams, a protective waterproof fabric, and a chest bib to keep the powder from getting into the pants from above. We used these bibs in driving snow and howling winds and felt as protected as we did while wearing the burliest Gore-Tex bibs.
The pants consist of a three-layer hard shell fabric made with Mammut's DRYtechnology Pro waterproof and breathable membrane. This material is softer than most Gore-Tex fabrics, but we find that it protects us nearly as well. We couldn't feel the wind through these pants, and they are just as waterproof as the best of them.
The bib design on these pants is different than most others; the torso component is made from a thin, stretchy, and breathable fabric that closely hugs the body. The bib material isn't waterproof, but these pants still keep out any snow that might penetrate up underneath a jacket.
Fit and Comfort
The Haldigrat fits better than most other pants on the market. The legs are slightly articulated and well-tailored, allowing a comfortable fit without being too tight. The legs are the perfect width, not too tight and not too loose. The same can be said about the waist and crotch. There are two hook-and-loop flaps on the outside of the beltline that allow the waist fit to be customized, and we find that the fit doesn't suffer if the tester tightens the waist belt all the way. It's an excellent design.
The hardshell material itself feels slightly stretchy, probably because of how soft it is. We didn't feel restricted when making long lunge movements while skinning uphill.
The bib component fits snugly around the user's torso, from the waistline to the bottom of the pectoral muscles. This is a different bib design than what most users are accustomed to, but we find that it increases comfort and mobility because it eliminates the need for lots of baggy material around the torso. It allows the Haldigrat to feel like a normal pair of pants instead of bibs, which is a comfortable upgrade.
Ventilation
The Haldigrat HS features a breathable hard shell fabric that allows decent ventilation, perhaps slightly better than Gore-Tex competitors, but not by much. The main ventilation features are two zippered outer thigh vents that measure 12 inches long.
These two vents are placed a little lower than we prefer, starting right above the knee and extending up toward the middle thigh. We like vents that are placed a little higher, by the upper thigh, and close to the torso, where we produce more body heat. The upper body bib on these pants is much more breathable than any other bib, thanks to the permeable material placed around the torso.
Warmth
Like most hardshell pants, these bibs won't keep the user warm on their own. The material effectively keeps out inclement weather, including cold wind, but the shell is thin, and heat is easily conducted away from the body while sitting on cold chairlift seats. You'll need to wear the appropriate base layers to keep warm.
Bibs often trap more warm air around the critical torso area than normal pants, and the Haldigrat is no exception. However, rather than capturing heat in the upper body with a thick, less breathable hard shell “pouch,” the Haldigrat adds warmth by using the torso bib as an additional polyester baselayer. In our testing, this added a small amount of overall warmth compared to a hardshell lower body pant.
Features
The Mammut Haldigrat HS has smart features that don't overload the user. There are two thigh pockets, each large enough to hold multiple items, like a cell phone, wallet, car keys, or avalanche transceiver. One of the thigh pockets has a sleeve for a cell phone or transceiver, though there isn't an internal loop for a transceiver leash to clip. The chest pocket does have a transceiver loop.
The cuffs have scuff guards, which are stiff enough to fend off sharp ski edges and crampon points without adding too much weight. There are elastic powder cuff gaiters and metal buttons on the outside of the shell cuffs to reduce the circumference while bootpacking.
Style
We love the style of these pants. They feature clean lines and an athletic fit without too much baggy material. These high-performance bibs aren't as loose and “steezy” as other pants, but we think they strike the perfect balance between performance and cool.
Freeride style is all the rage these days, and these pants have a performance look that lets people know that you like to look good, but you like to ski even better. Also, the style is versatile, fitting in with all crowds, from the ski bum bar to the billionaire club.
Should You Buy the Mammut Haldigrat HS?
These pants outperform the rest with excellent versatility and awesome features. They are protective enough for stormy days at the ski resort and breathable enough for long ski tours. We think these are the best bibs for a wide variety of users, and only very occasional skiers or those looking for niche pants should look elsewhere.
What Other Ski Pants Should You Consider?
These pants cover the needs of most users, but they are not the best for everyone. If you are looking for a much cheaper bib alternative, The North Face Freedom Bib is the best value on the market, but it won't compare to the fit, comfort, and protection of the Haldigrat. If you want a non-bib pant with great features, the Norrona Lofoten Gore-Tex has tons of pockets and a roomier fit. If style is your most important consideration, but you still want a good pair of pants, the Arc'teryx Sabre Pant looks great and performs as well.