We buy all the products we test — no freebies from companies. If you purchase through our links, we may earn a commission, which helps support our testing.
We traveled via plane, train, and automobile with checked luggage from Travelpro, Briggs & Riley, Osprey, Eagle Creek, Samsonite, and more to help you hone in on the best travel companion
Our globetrotting experts bought and tested 24 of the best, most popular, and most promising checked bag luggage on the market. We stacked them into vehicles, packed them for business trips and backcountry adventures, and tested every feature along the way. We put them through the wringer — bumping them over gravel and cobblestones, shoving them down cement stairs, and spraying them with a hose.
Our absolute favorite piece of checked baggage for many years in a row now — and the one we recommend to most travelers — is the Travelpro Platinum Elite 29". It has an excellent suite of organizational features for extended travel and a sturdy exterior that easily withstands the rigors of airline baggage systems. Exceptionally smooth, self-aligning wheels make getting to your final destination a breeze — and the look of this bag is rather stylish. All this, combined with a tendency to go on sale regularly, makes this suitcase an exceptional value for all kinds of travelers.
For less frequent travelers and those with a more modest budget, the SwissGear Sion 29" is a no-frills suitcase with an impressive 87-liter expandable capacity and handy exterior pockets. If you're a fan of hardshell models, the Samsonite Freeform is a solid, lightweight, and budget-friendly model with a built-in lock to keep your belongings safer during transit.
If you're not sure you need this much space, we've also tested a slew of great carry-on luggages that might better suit your travel needs. For anyone who doesn't want a “box on wheels,” an oversized duffel is a great alternative. Check out our packing advice to see if other travel bags or accessories might make your trip even better.
Editor's Note: This review was updated on November 21, 2024, after retesting the newest version of the Patagonia Black Hole and adding six new bags from Osprey, REI, Samsonite, Travelers Club, and more to our extensive lineup.
Inexpensive, rolls easily, large capacity, smooth zipper
Bargain price point, reasonably sturdy, tons of packing space, TSA locks, good color options
Inexpensive, ample storage, good organizational features, smooth zippers
Decent weight, large packing area, good price, ships as a five-piece set, lots of color options
Cons
Bulky and cumbersome, may be too large for some travelers
A little pricey, stiff zippers, lacks full-length bumpers
Extremely costly, prone to scratch, shell is completely exposed to contact
Thinner fabric, unsteady when upright, limited exterior handles, lacks bumper rails, not very water-resistant, no exterior compression straps
Unnecessary extras for average travel, bulky tactical design
Very expensive, heavy, difficult to roll on mixed terrain
Shell fabric is a little too thin, stiff main zipper, not very water-resistant
Shows scuffs and dirt, heavy, not as waterproof as hoped, a little unsteady when fully weighted, a little pricey, zippers sometimes catch when packed to max
Balances simplicity with adventure-friendly design
Useful organizational and compression features
Substantial carrying capacity
Water-resistant
Self-aligning wheels
REASONS TO AVOID
May be too large for some travelers
Somewhat heavy and bulky
It's big, beautiful, and built to last. The Travelpro Platinum Elite 29" continues to be our favorite overall suitcase over the past several years for more reasons than we can fit into this small paragraph, but we'll give it our best effort — please fasten your seat belts. To begin, this bag is huge. If you're headed for a month overseas or have a wardrobe that rivals royalty, We hand-measured its main compartment and calculated 117 liters of packing space. We're certain this monster spinner has the trunk space you need.
“This large, well-organized behemoth is practically a closet on wheels.”
Even when packed to the gills, the Platinum Elite glides like a speed skater through busy airports and packed city streets. Its proprietary MagnaTrac spinners seamlessly self-align using internal magnets, uniformly pointing forward as you roll this bag along your side. It also boasts smooth zippers, stylish accents, and a very rugged nylon shell.
SPECIFICATIONS
Exterior Dimensions
29.5" x 20.0." x 12.75"
Weight (Measured)
12.2 lb
Main Compartment Volume (Measured)
117 L
Exterior Material
High-density nylon fabric with DuraGuard
Number of Wheels
4
The Platinum Elite will appeal to both business travelers and jet-setters who need a secure place to store their business clothes or formal wear. When it comes to packing uniforms, formals, or other important clothing, the Platinum Elite's fold-away suiter is one of the best in the industry at artfully tucking away suits, skirts, and dresses for a wrinkle-free ride. However, we do feel the packing system of the Briggs & Riley Baseline Large Expandable Spinner is just a little bit better.
“It has buttery smooth zippers, a great compression system, and just enough style to stand out in the crowd.”
The Platinum Elite's main compartment has two large compression panels that buckle and cinch over the rest of your clothing, shoes, and accessories, holding them securely in place, regardless of what turbulence lies ahead. That said, this bag's packing system is very specific, so it may not appeal to more casual travelers who prefer wide-open compartments that don't limit their packing style. As we said, this bag is big, so it may simply be too large for less extensive travel or for frequent flyers who like to pack light. It tips the scales at 12.2 pounds, which could impact the Platinum Elite's packable payload after factoring in standard weight restrictions enforced by airlines.
Headed for the check-in counter at Salt Lake City International Airport.
Credit: Jason Wanlass
No piece of luggage is perfect, but when we consider the pluses and minuses, the Platinum Elite is still our favorite. If you don't mind a higher price tag, this bag should be on your shortlist, especially if you value quality. We also love its smaller siblings, the Platinum Elite 25" and the carry-on sized Platinum Elite 21", which offer the same amenities but alternate sizes. No other checked-size luggage we tested matches the performance and price of this seriously impressive bag. The only ones that come close are the duffel-style The North Face Base Camp Rolling Thunder 28, Eagle Creek ORV Trunk 30, Osprey Sojourn Shuttle, or the premium hard-sided Rimowa Essential Check-In (but that comes at a very premium price).
Making double time with our Platinum Elite at our side. Although huge, this bag rolls well on all surfaces, and is ready to keep pace with you wherever you go.
With a brand reputation built on quality and reliability that has spanned more than a century, it may come as no surprise that the Samsonite Freeform garnered acceptable marks across all metrics in our test suite, making it a shoo-in for our best budget-friendly hardshell spinner. Although the suitcase is massive — possibly oversized for some basic travel needs — its simple, attractive, and oh-so-practical design should still place this well-priced clamshell spinner up for consideration on any urban traveler's checked luggage list. We do admit the Away The Large outperformed the Freeform in construction quality (because it has a more rugged shell) and functionality (thanks to its super cool internal compression system) — but costs significantly more.
SPECIFICATIONS
Exterior Dimensions
31.1" x 20.9" x 13.8"
Weight (Measured)
9.4 lb
Main Compartment Volume (Measured)
112.5 L
Exterior Material
Polypropylene
Number of Wheels
4
Constructed from extra-sturdy polypropylene, we loved this hulk of a bag because it looks smaller than it really is — we measured 112.5 liters of internal volume! — thanks to Samsonite's latest redesign of its entire fleet of products. We are most impressed with this model's four double-wheeled spinners, which are a massive improvement over the manufacturer's previous wheel of choice. These new treads roll smoother and are much more responsive. We also loved this model's TSA-approved combo lock and sliding name tag. The Showkoo Hardside Set rolls just as smoothly as the Freeform, and it maintains a straight line better. It also ships as a three-piece luggage set, which makes it a very appealing option. However, our testing found the overall quality of the Showkoo set to be lower than the Freeform.
“A well-built suitcase that's tough enough to withstand baggage claim a few trips each year.”
We had no trouble spotting our purple Samsonite on the carousel.
Credit: Jason Wanlass
This piece of checked luggage will make the average traveler happy because it won't break the bank and will hold up reasonably well over time. Common travelers who check a bag one to three times per year will enjoy the packability of this large case but will also be impressed with its overall durability and reliability. We're not suggesting this bag is shatterproof — rather, it's an above-average bargain bag made for light to moderate travel. However, with proper care, the average traveler could enjoy the Freeform for several travel seasons.
“Basic features, yet rugged, stylish, and smooth-cruising.”
Price-conscious flyers should also take a look at the Delsey Paris Titanium. However, if bargain barrel shopping is more your vibe, the Amazon Basics 30" and the Travelers Club Chicago are worth a look-see. We love that the Travelers Club ships as a five-piece set, although we weren't as wowed with this set's overall quality.
The SwissGear Sion embodies the spirit of our favorite soft-sided checked suitcases with an understated yet classic softshell design. However, the features and amenities of the Sion Softside are more bare-bones, and its fabric shell is thinner and noticeably less sinewy. That said, we feel this bag is made well, offers impressive packing volume — we measured 87 liters in the main compartment — and is durable enough to undergo the rigors of airline travel with moderate frequency.
“A relatively simple suitcase that still has two external pockets and a detachable toiletries bag.”
We feel the Sion Softside will appeal to travelers looking for great value at a very reasonable price, which is why we unanimously named it our favorite affordable softshell, but the Timbuk2 Copilot did outperform it in every metric. In fact, the Timbuk2 is one of our favorite softshells. It has a very unique style and rolls on bonafide skateboard wheels — it's also more than double the cost.
SPECIFICATIONS
Exterior Dimensions
28.5" x 17.25" x 12.5"
Weight (Measured)
11.1 lb
Main Compartment Volume (Measured)
87 L
Exterior Material
Polyester
Number of Wheels
4
The Sion Softside's polyester shell isn't as thick as ballistic nylon, but it is still quite rugged. Its wheels aren't as tall or smooth-rolling as our top spinners, but they roll well enough to get you from A to B. Likewise, this bag's packing system isn't nearly as plush as other softshells on our list, but it offers nice, wide-open space that can swallow up enough clothes, shoes, and accessories for a week-long trip. But keep in mind that the Sion Softside tends to leak when exposed to water, its wheels shutter and rattle at higher speeds, and we question the longevity of its zippers after years of use.
“You get what you pay for with the Sion — a good deal that does well enough for less frequent travel.”
The Sion's handles are cheap and basic, but they perform well enough for the occasional snag and grab from the baggage claim carousel.
Credit: Jason Wanlass
There's something to be said for balancing cost, construction quality, and function. It's called a good deal. We don't recommend the Sion Softside for frequent, extensive travel. Although we saw no serious wear and tear during our testing, the Sion Softside simply doesn't compete with the quality of more expensive softshells, like the Travelpro Platinum Elite 29" or the Dakine Split Roller. Many of the international travelers on our panel feel that repeated, long-haul travel may be too much turbulence for the Sion. That said, it's perfectly suitable for moderate domestic trips or an occasional jaunt overseas.
The Amazon Basics 30" is a solid utilitarian option for the ultra-price-conscious. Though it performed reasonably well across all our tests, its biggest selling point is the low price tag. Four large, rubberized double-spinner wheels won't guarantee the sharpest of turns when navigating busy airports, but they will make for a relatively smooth and stable experience under most flat-surfaced conditions. In comparison, rocky and off-road landscapes prove substantially more challenging. Fortunately, a telescoping rolling handle and two top and side grab options can help you load and carry the suitcase through varied environments.
“If low-key design, basic functionality, and a low price point are your top priorities, you'll find them here.”
Our favorite feature is this bag's large, clamshell design. Our testing measurements showed it offers 84 liters of packing space, including a couple of bonus organizational extras — two mesh pockets inlaid into one half-clam panel area, and a smaller accessory pocket hung on the opposing side. Plus, if you're a shopper, a single zipper expands the bag by another 15 percent to accommodate bulky souvenirs. In terms of capacity, the only better hardshell option in our lineup is the Samsonite Omni PC Hardside. Our hand measurements of its interior resulted in 108 liters of volume, and it has a slightly better-quality shell.
SPECIFICATIONS
Exterior Dimensions
30.75" x 21.0" x 12.0
Weight (Measured)
11.6 lb
Main Compartment Volume (Measured)
84 L
Exterior Material
Extra-thick ABS, hard shell
Number of Wheels
4
Unfortunately, the Amazon Basics has a tendency to rotate outward on a vertical axis when walking uphill (rather than rolling with you in parallel). And like many hard-sided bags, the zipper sometimes sticks a bit when coming around corners. So, there are some minor inconveniences to consider. However, the most pressing consideration has to be durability. Both interior and exterior materials appear very average in quality, but this bag stood up reasonably against the rigors of our testing, well enough to win notice.
“For simple, short, infrequent travel, this inexpensive bag is a solid — if less durable — option.”
Using a little elbow grease to put the final zip on packing. This bag isn't a bad option if you're trying to thriftily outfit the entire family with luggage for that once-a-year trip.
Credit: Jason Wanlass
If a shorter life span is acceptable for your needs, this strikingly affordable and well-sized four-wheel suitcase will do the trick. If you need the cheapest option that still functionally gets you there, this suitcase can't be beaten. It will appeal to travelers looking for a quick buy for a last-minute trip or for families or large groups looking to outfit a number of people at a reasonable cost — although when we consider only price, not quality, we do feel the five-piece Travelers Club Chicago is the better deal. Be warned, though, that either option is reasonably solid at first, but you most certainly will get the overall quality you pay for. If the thought of cheaper luggage is too much turbulence for your brain, you may want to splurge a little more for the Samsonite Freeform Large Spinner or the Delsey Paris Titanium. Both scored higher and offered far better overall performance in our tests.
Straightjacket compression system holds gear in place
REASONS TO AVOID
Lacks full-length bumper rails
Stiff zippers
Somewhat pricey
The Osprey Sojourn Shuttle excels at gobbling up gear and keeping it snuggly in place with its straitjacket compression system. This two-wheeler is specifically designed to carry a wide variety of outdoor gear to nearly any corner of the globe. Complemented by a supporting cast of a padded ballistic nylon shell, massive sealed-bearing wheels, and a comprehensive metal frame, this bag is well-suited for rigorous adventure travel.
“This bag easily makes the transition from baggage claim to porter to pack animal.”
We loved that the Sojourn Shuttle is shaped and compartmentalized like a backpacking pack. It's also ergonomically bowed, making it more suitable for transportation by pack animal, porter, or luggage rack than any gear hauler we've studied. Even better, it's super tough and incredibly lightweight, earning it one of the higher weight-to-volume ratios on our list — we measured it at 8.7 pounds and 99 liters.
If you're simply looking for one of the toughest gear haulers available, we think this is an A++ choice. A full-length interior metal frame and super tough fabrics don't come cheap, so expect to pay a little more for the top-tier quality. The Sojourn Shuttle also lacks protective bumper rails, like the ones on the back of The North Face Base Camp Rolling Thunder 28, which are designed to allow bags to slide rather than tumble end over end when falling down staircases or landing on hard surfaces. The beefy zippers are super tough, which makes them a bit difficult to use, but the trade-off is zippers that won't split open during the rigors of international travel. Additionally, we feel this bag's pack volume could fall short of accommodating large amounts of gear needed for an extensive trip, and we feel travelers who need a more systematically spaced packing system may opt for the compartmental layout of the Eagle Creek ORV Trunk 30.
“Its design is great for jet-setters hitting the slopes, clipping into carabiners, or lacing up hiking boots.”
We looked at even the smallest feature to determine its quality. Even something as simple as a zipper pull can make a lot of difference.
Credit: Jason Wanlass
For larger expeditions, we recommend the Sojourn Shuttle's 130-liter model. We also really loved the The North Face Base Camp Rolling Thunder and the Osprey Daylite Wheeled Duffel 85. Both performed well across all our testing. In particular, the Daylite is much lighter (6.8 pounds) than any of the adventure models on our list, and we loved that it can be quickly converted into a backpack if your travel plans include a jaunt or two off-grid. However, when it comes to gear, sometimes simpler is better, so check out our review duffel bags] if you want to consider other options for long-hauling your stuff.
Rolling smoothly alongside you, pivoting on a dime across smooth surfaces, and negotiating gravel and cobblestones using only average strength, the four-wheeled Briggs & Riley Baseline is our favorite soft-sided premium suitcase because it screams high quality without looking flashy. Three loading handles give it an edge when your haul includes rough terrain, or you're grabbing it off the baggage claim carousel, but what really sets this bag apart is its spot-on organizational features.
“A unique design and innovative expansion system keep things organized and wrinkle-free.”
Some of our favorite features include a small external SpeedThru pocket to keep necessities close at hand, plus a larger front sleeve pocket to stash entertainment or layers on the go. Inside the suitcase's primary zip-flap opening is a tri-fold garment envelope with two zipped pockets that fold out to accommodate delicate fabric items and minimize wrinkles. Meanwhile, compression panels and an ingenious CX expansion system inside the main compartment are available to keep your belongings in place while enabling you to pack far more than meets the eye, all without making the bag any bigger.
SPECIFICATIONS
Exterior Dimensions
29.0" x 20.25" x 12.5"
Weight (Measured)
13.7 lb
Main Compartment Volume (Measured)
92.5 L
Exterior Material
1680D ballistic nylonD
Number of Wheels
4
The Baseline will appeal to travelers who simply want the best quality, but it will also draw in anyone who likes highly compartmentalized packing features. From airline personnel to business travelers, anyone who needs to pack uniforms or other important clothing will love the Baseline's storage capabilities. However, there are two notable downsides to this high-quality spinner — its cost and its higher-than-average weight. So, if either of these are dealbreakers, we think the lighter, less-expensive Travelpro Platinum Elite is a better deal.
“Though pricey, this case continues to be one of our favorite models we've ever tested.”
Closing the deal just in time to head to make our flight.
Credit: Jason Wanlass
While the Baseline is the heaviest case we tested, at 13.7 pounds, yet surprisingly did not match that high base weight with an impressive capacity — we measured just 92.5 liters, which is average among our testing lineup. But given its superior performance across all metrics, we still feel there's a lot to justify the extra investment. Everything we saw during testing indicates it's built to last. Plus, with the company's renowned unconditional lifetime guarantee, you can repair any components or features that may break over time. We did note some vulnerabilities when it comes to water exposure under testing. So, we wouldn't count on this case to provide watertight protection in transit under harsh conditions. The Baseline is expensive, so if you're okay with paying more upfront for travel gear with a superb compression system and a design that will outlast the competition, this could be the right option for you.
Absolutely zero uncertainty prevailed during our decision to name this high-value travel chest our favorite luxury harshell. Our selection was based on our testing, but its heritage is also notable. In the case of Rimowa, they've been making luggage since 1898. The Rimowa Essential Check-In L was born out of a long history of all things trunks and cases, so our modern-day industry of “movement” is nothing new.
“This bag is made with the finest materials and is ideal for extensive business or leisure travel.”
This stylish case carries things and carries them well. We love that it's engineered to be the best and has a fabulous look and design. It's also quite expensive. However, don't expect any apologies. The Essential is built to last. After running it through our gamut of punishing tests, we can confidently say this bag is durable, relentlessly smooth-rolling, garners the limelight, and proffers an amazing storage process.
SPECIFICATIONS
Exterior Dimensions
30.6" x 20.5" x 11.1"
Weight (Measured)
10.6 lb
Main Compartment Volume (Measured)
90 L
Exterior Material
Polycarbonate
Number of Wheels
4
All fancy verbiage aside, the Essential Check-in simply delivers. Our negative note-taking was minimal, though the obvious elephant in the room is this suitcase's enormously high price. Our only structural complaint is that this spinner's ultra-polished polycarbonate shell has no protection. After a tumble or two, it shows scratches and scuffs easily — a bit of a letdown especially when considering the up-front investment.
“It stands out in a crowd and rolls smoothly for miles.”
However, any way you slice it, quality is quality, and this bag is perfectly comfortable being the best. So, if you are in the market for a top brand name, the Essential will definitely appeal to you. It's well-built and flight-ready for any destination around the globe. Specifically, we think this bag will also appeal to business travelers who frequently book extensive travel. That said, while the Rimowa Check-In is impressive in all areas, its price tag is simply unappealing to many travelers.
Testing our Rimowa's wheels on a rural dirt road.
Credit: Jason Wanlass
If you're in the market for a different slant on premium hard-sided luggage, the Tumi 19 Degree Extended Trip is another high-quality, good-looking bag with a top-shelf price. We're also very big fans of the Away The Large suitcase, which has high marks in our testing, a premium look, and a more reasonable price.
Cruising the terminal with our Rimowa. These wheels are so smooth they barely make a sound.
Credit: Jason Wanlass
Compare Products
We used and abused these suitcases for months to find out which ones can survive the baggage system of your standard airport.
Credit: Jason Wanlass
How We Test Luggage
We traveled across the West, from California's Yosemite and Eastern Sierra to Central Oregon, Utah, and Colorado, with plenty of stops in between. We visited Europe, Korea, Nepal, and Tibet and spent more hours in airports and airplanes than we care to count. We research the best candidates each year before handpicking our lineup of the best, most popular, and most intriguing models. We then purchased all of these bags and took them everywhere we went over the course of several months. We rolled them along sidewalks, through the airport, over cobblestone pathways, and deep out onto rocky backcountry roads. We traveled with them in the back of trucks, SUVs, and tucked into vans. At home, we set up obstacle courses, rolling them over and around different objects and hucking them down stairwells and onto concrete. We even hosed them down with water to see which could repel light rain. In total, our bags saw thousands of miles of travel and hundreds of combined hours of testing. Read more in our complete how we test article.
Our comprehensive testing was divided into four testing metrics:
• Capacity (35% of overall score weighting)
• Ease of Transport (25% weighting)
• Construction Quality (20% weighting)
• Design and Functionality (20% weighting)
Why Trust GearLab
This thorough testing of suitcases is led by GearLab Review Editors Jason Wanlass and Myrha Colt. Both are frequent travelers, spending many weeks each year living out of their suitcases. It is not uncommon for Myrha to be on the road for nearly half (or more) of any given year, with days spent traveling between mountain hideaways, remote beach villages, city skyscrapers, and all the backcountry roads, trails, museums, waterfalls, and taco stands she can squeeze in between. Jason loves adventuring to unique corners of the globe, particularly mountainous regions. He enjoys the thrill of hiking in the most famous mountain ranges in the world, which usually involves lugging boatloads of gear around in hefty, gear-hauler suitcases. Mountains are his first love, but airports are a close second. Jason loves all things travel and is on the go whenever he can find the time. Both of our reviewers have traveled to five or more continents, exploring big cities, small towns, and rugged high-country destinations. Each of them tests gear for a living and knows a thing or two about packing their bags and what makes a good one.
Adventure ready wardrobe list ready to be packed in each test suitcase.
Adventure wardrobe packed into the Amazon Basics 30" Hardsided Spinner Suitcase.
With three distinct compartments, you can fit a surprising amount into the soft-sided clamshell Dakine Split Roller even without an expansion option.
We packed, unpacked, and then packed again.
How to Pick the Best Luggage for You
Here are four key considerations to help narrow down your next luggage selection based on size, organization, material type, and features.
How Many Belongings Do You Travel With?
The first step to finding a suitable piece of luggage is considering your average belongings and the length of trips you plan on taking. Overpacking or bringing an oversized bag can diminish an otherwise great vacation or trip. Factors such as checking in your bag or using a carry-on will dictate an appropriate size, along with how much walking between places you plan on doing. It's also important to consider weight constrictions, as the larger your bag, the more likely you will run out of allowable weight.
How Much Organization Do You Prefer?
Different luggage will offer various levels of organization to provide easy access and maximize space. For folks who need to access belongings more frequently, luggage with convenient pockets and storage can make a significant difference. Additionally, organizational pockets can provide more storage to make sure you leave nothing behind. Looking for features such as interior pockets, dividers, and access points are all good areas to consider for those needing plenty of organization.
Quick-access exterior pockets are a simple but highly useful feature.
Credit: Jason Wanlass
Do You Prefer Soft or Hardshell Luggage?
When deciding on luggage, a hardshell will provide increased durability and resistance to impacts. If you plan on checking your bag, a hard shell will provide extra peace of mind when it's not in your possession. A softshell will be lighter, allowing more flexibility when packing items. Ultimately, the items you travel with and the type of travel will dictate what style is best for your needs.
How Important is Ease of Transportation?
For travelers who plan on navigating hubs such as airports and train stations, luggage with smooth rolling wheels, telescoping handles, and ergonomic features will enhance your travel experience. Consider whether you prefer four-wheeled luggage with more maneuverability vs. two-wheeled bags with increased stability. Also worth considering is the length of the handles for different-sized folks and to help reduce strain on hands and arms.
Moving through the airport with ease thanks to a sturdy handle and smooth rolling wheels.
Credit: Jason Wanlass
Analysis and Test Results
We compared our tested suitcases across four key metrics and evaluated them side-by-side in the field and at home. We packed the same set of clothes and gear in each to compare their storage and organizational capacity. We rolled them around trip after trip to see how easy they were to transport, carry, and load. We pushed them hard to see their reliability, weighed them, and took stock of their style. The winners are the ones that scored the best and the ones we would recommend to our own friends and family. Read on to learn more about how each performed to help inform your final purchase decision.
What's the Best Value?
Often, you get what you pay for, and we've rarely come across a high-quality, low-cost roller case. If you want well-made luggage that's likely to last, it will likely be expensive. That said, some of these bags are well-made and reasonably priced. The Timbuk2 Copilot isn't the most or least expensive of the roller suitcases we tested, but it scored very well in our tests and has a middle-of-the-road price as well as the multi-terrain functionality of a two-wheeler. It's still an investment, but we think it's a good one.
It's a good idea to check out the manufacturer's warranty to see if you'll have any options for repair or replacement if your bag breaks.
Some of the best value buys, in terms of volume per dollar, are some of the wheeled duffel bags. In particular, The North Face Base Camp Rolling Thunder 28 and the Dakine Split Roller 85L perform pretty well and can get you where you need to go for less.
If a duffel bag isn't for you, the Samsonite Freeform Large is a pretty reasonable price and also offers excellent performance and notable durability for a spinner suitcase. The Amazon Basics 30" Hardshell is the least expensive in our lineup and still performed quite well in many of our tests. While its composition appears less durable than most of the other options, it still works well, especially if you'll only be traveling occasionally. On the other hand, if you're a frequent traveler who likes to stay organized, the Travelpro Platinum Elite 29" is well worth the investment.
With so many luggage brands to choose from, it can be a daunting process to wade through all the specifics of each in order to determine value. That's why we took the time to do it for you in our side-by-side comparative testing.
Credit: Jason Wanlass
Lastly, though they didn't score as well as some of our top performers, but we do want to mention the Showkoo Expandable Hardside Set 28" and Travelers Club Chicago 28". Both ship as full three-piece and five-piece luggage sets (respectively), which brings added value for both products.
Comparative Details Across Checked Luggage
Measured Volume
Number of Wheels
Locking Mechanism
Exterior Pockets
Travelpro Platinum Elite 29"
117 L
4
Combination/TSA lock
2
Rimowa Essential Check-In L
90 L
4
Combination/TSA lock
None
Osprey Sojourn Shuttle 100L
99 L
2
Zipper loop
4
Eagle Creek ORV Trunk 30
99.5 L
2
Zipper loop
3
Osprey Daylite Wheeled Duffle 85
78.o L
2
Zipper loop
3
Briggs & Riley Baseline Large Expandable Spinner
92.5 L
4
Zipper loop
2
The North Face Base Camp Rolling Thunder 28
96.7 L
2
Zipper loop
2
REI Co-op Big Haul Rolling Duffel 30"
88.1 L
2
Zipper loop
2
Eagle Creek Cargo Hauler XT 32"
108.5 L
2
Zipper loop
2
Tumi 19 Degree Extended Trip Expandable
85.5 L
4
Combination/TSA lock
None
Dakine Split Roller 85L
77.5 L
2
Zipper loop
2
Cotopaxi Allpa 65L Roller
60.3 L
2
Zipper loop
1
Timbuk2 Copilot
99.5 L
2
Zipper loop
2
Away The Large
85.2 L
4
Combination/TSA lock
None
Samsonite Freeform Large Spinner
112.5 L
4
Combination/TSA lock
None
Patagonia Black Hole Wheeled
77.5 L
2
None
2
Samsonite Omni PC Hardside Expandable
108 L
4
Combination/TSA lock
None
Delsey Paris Titanium Hardside 29"
98 L
4
Combination/TSA lock
None
Showkoo Expandable Hardside Set 28"
99.5 L
4
Combination/TSA lock
None
SwissGear Sion Softside Expandable Roller 29"
87 L
4
Zipper loop
2
Amazon Basics 30" Hardside Spinner
84 L
4
None
None
Coolife Hardside Expandable 28"
101 L
4
Combination/TSA lock
None
Kenneth Cole Reaction Out Of Bounds 28"
82.5 L
4
Zipper loop
None
Travelers Club Chicago 28"
97.0 L
4
Zipper loop
None
Capacity
We compared each model's volume, compartments, pockets, compression, and organization straps. To do so, we packed, unpacked, and hand-measured each bag's interior dimensions and weighed each to determine their weight-to-volume ratios. Bags that offered either thoughtful organization or ample storage capacity scored higher in this category.
One of our favorites for this metric is the Travelpro Platinum Elite 29". Its main compartment offers 117 liters of volume and an extensive storage and organizational system. The Samsonite Freeform Large is also a standout in this metric, boasting 112.5 liters of volume and standing tall as our most spacious hardshell. The Delsey Paris Titanium 29" (98 liters) is another affordable hardshell that also offers a ton of space.
Airline Weight Restrictions
Just because you can fit your entire wardrobe into some of these suitcases doesn't mean you should. Most airlines start charging fees once a bag weighs more than 50 pounds. We found it's very easy to overpack these bags far beyond that weight limit, so perhaps keep a scale handy while you pack.
These bags are followed closely by the Timbuk2 Copilot and its 99.5-liter interior. In particular, the Copilot is a soft-sided suitcase, but at the same time, it is unique among softshells for offering a clamshell design, unzipping down the middle so you can load gear evenly on both sides.
Although light on cool features, the Samsonite Freeform's interior is massive, allowing it to accommodate a wide variety of payloads.
Credit: Jason Wanlass
Unlike most similar clamshell-style suitcases, the Copilot one has both sides covered with a zippered mesh panel, so nothing spills as you open it, and a couple of additional mesh pockets for interior organization. You can also access your packed items from a U-shaped opening across the topside, which we love.
Hopped out of our cab, and now hitting the city streets en route to our downtown hotel. The Copilot's skateboard wheels make cruising a few blocks a breeze.
Credit: Jason Wanlass
Well-known for their massive interiors are the duffel-style rollers or gear haulers. These two-wheeler cases traditionally offer a softshell duffel top that is supported by a more dense hardshell-type tray bottom. Primarily designed to transport a mix of clothing and outdoor gear, these bags offer wide-open main compartments.
The most voluminous duffel roller on our list is the Eagle Creek Cargo Hauler XT 32", offering 108.5 liters of main compartment packing space. This wide mouth can swallow an entire 75-liter backpack and still have room for everything else you plan to take to base camp.
Sometimes testing can be fun. Just for kicks, we wanted to see if our 75-liter backpack could fit inside the Eagle Creek Cargo Hauler XT. Duffel rollers often offer large volume.
Credit: Jason Wanlass
Other top-performing gear haulers in this metric are the Eagle Creek ORV Trunk 30 (we measured 99.5 liters), Osprey Sojourn Shuttle 100L (99 liters), and the The North Face Base Camp Rolling Thunder 28 (96.7 liters). The ORV Trunk is a great choice for adventure travel, thanks to its many pockets and practical organizational features. This soft-sided case offers a lot of storage, an expandable wet/dry compartment, and easily holds bulky items. This is a great option if you need to bring big boots or camera gear on a long travel mission. It even has a bungee cord and daisy-chain loops to attach a helmet or other gear to the outside of the bag if you run out of space inside.
Using the Equipment Keeper to quickly strap a loose helmet into place before loading our ORV Trunk into the truck. This bag has tons of unique accessories that make it a cut above other gear haulers.
Credit: Jason Wanlass
Our testers used The North Face Base Camp Rolling Thunder 28 extensively for international adventure travel. They fell in love with its capacity to haul everything from clothing to souvenirs to gear. Although its main compartment doesn't boast the largest packing volume, this bag offers a layout, a very sturdy compression panel, and a large exterior zippered compartment.
Heading out: packing up in the cool morning air as we get ready to leave Kathmandu, Nepal. The Northface Base Camp Rolling Thunder's large interior and sturdy compression panel make it easy to fit everything, including a large trove of souvenirs.
Credit: Jason Wanlass
Similarly, the soft-sided Dakine Split Roller 85L (77.5 liters) is a roller duffel with a clamshell design that includes mesh panels for interior organization. Although it offers ample storage space and organizational options, in the end, the Split Roller scored lower because it lacks the convenience of the top-sided entry that proves so valuable on the Timbuk2 Copilot.
Packing up and heading home. Although it doesn't offer the most volume, the Dakine Split Roller makes up for it with great organizational skills.
Credit: Jason Wanlass
The Briggs & Riley Baseline Spinner is one of the more spacious premium suitcases on our list. It offers close to 92.5 liters of storage and a unique expansion and compression system that lets you add volume by growing the main compartment, packing it full, and then compressing the entire bag down again. It works surprisingly well. There's also a tri-fold hanging compartment, nicely placed external pockets for day-of organization, and an attachable SmartLink strap to help you carry a second bag. This is an excellent option for the frequent flyer who likes to see and access what's in their luggage easily.
Looking sharp was our Briggs & Riley heads for the check-in counter.
Credit: Jason Wanlass
The Travelpro Platinum Elite 29" has a very similar setup to the Briggs & Riley Baseline, but instead of expanding and compressing, it provides an external expansion zipper that reveals a tapered opening along the front lid, offering some additional capacity toward the base of the bag. The overall impact on packing space is limited, and this isn't the ideal place to carry such extra weight, as the bag can easily become front-heavy and start to tip when standing. However, the pockets are quite well-organized, and the internal hanging compartment will help keep your nice clothes less wrinkly in transit.
Testing our Travelpro's ability to fold up a business suit, as well as swallow up all of our leisure clothing. It ate it all like a frog in a mosquito factory.
Credit: Jason Wanlass
The Away The Large, Amazon Basics 30" Hardside, and Kenneth Cole Reaction Out Of Bounds 28" are all hard-sided and feature clamshell designs with a fair amount of space. Of these, we like the Away The Large bag (85.2 liters) the best for including an internal compression panel similar to those found in the Rimowa Check-In. It maximizes packing space along with a zippered panel enclosure, which allows for great double-sided packing. It even includes a separate laundry bag to keep your dirty clothing separate.
Enduring a layover with our Away. We love its storage capacity and its good looks.
Credit: Jason Wanlass
Lastly, our testing resulted in top scores in this metric for the Osprey Daylite Wheeled Duffel 85. Our measurements of its main compartment calculated a slightly smaller packing space (78 liters) when compared to many others we've tested. But what makes this bag unique is its weight. Tipping the scales at just 6.8 pounds, the Daylite is the lightest bag of them all, which translates to an amazing weight-to-volume ratio. This basically means that more of the bag's overall weight at the check-in counter is made up of your stuff, not the bag itself.
Weighing in at check-in, en route to Acadia National Park in Maine. Our Osprey Daylite was chock full of hiking gear and clothes, but it still came in well below our airline's weight requirements thanks to its lighter construction.
Credit: Jason Wanlass
Ease of Transport
Any wheeled luggage should be able to navigate the polished floors of an airport. But, as we all know, your luggage will also come across cracked sidewalks, steep curbs, and gravel-laden pavement. If you're traveling abroad in remote countries or into the outdoors, it's quite possible you'll also encounter dirt roads, cobblestone streets, and rocky trails. To see how our tested products hold up, we rolled each case over all types of terrain, taking note of which provided the smoothest ride.
In general, four-wheeled spinner options are ideal for smooth, hard surfaces since they can pivot and spin around any obstacle. Several of those in our lineup actually have eight wheels, two at every corner connected by an axle. However, our testing also took into account each case's ability to track (stay straight), wheel smoothness, handle smoothness, and ability to maintain balance when standing upright fully loaded.
It looks like play, but trust us, it's hard work -- sometimes. We loved playing around with our Tumi. Its wheels have one of the smoothest rides we've ever seen.
Credit: Jason Wanlass
If we specifically look at wheel performance, our top rollers include the Rimowa Essential Check-In, Travelpro Platinum Elite, and the Tumi 19 Degree Extended Trip. Each of these bags is on the expensive side (some are on the very expensive side), but there is no denying their effortlessly smooth glide.
Ease of Use of Specific Luggage Features
Product
Tracking Ability
Wheel Smoothness
Telescopic Handle Smoothness
Balance
Travelpro Platinum Elite 29\"
5
5
5
5
Briggs & Riley Baseline Large Expandable Spinner
4.5
5
5
5
Tumi 19 Degree Extended Trip Expandable
5
5
4.5
5
Rimowa Essential Check-In L
4.5
5
4.5
5
Timbuk2 Copilot
4
5
4
4
Osprey Sojourn Shuttle 100L
3
3.5
4
4
Away The Large
3.5
3.5
3
4
Eagle Creek ORV Trunk 30
3
3.5
4.5
3
Dakine Split Roller 85L
3
4
3.5
3.5
Samsonite Freeform Large Spinner
4
3
3
3.5
Showkoo Expandable Hardside Set 28\"
4
3.5
2.5
3.5
The North Face Base Camp Rolling Thunder 28
3
3
4
3
Patagonia Black Hole Wheeled
3
3
3.5
3
Osprey Daylite Wheeled Duffle 85
3
3.5
4
2
REI Co-op Big Haul Rolling Duffel 30\"
3
3
3.5
3
Cotopaxi Allpa 65L Roller
3
3
3
3
Eagle Creek Cargo Hauler XT 32\"
3
3
3
3
Delsey Paris Titanium Hardside 29\"
3
3
2.5
3
SwissGear Sion Softside Expandable Roller 29\"
2.5
2.5
3
3.5
Amazon Basics 30\" Hardside Spinner
3
2.5
2.5
3
Kenneth Cole Reaction Out Of Bounds 28\"
3
2.5
2.5
3
Samsonite Omni PC Hardside Expandable
2
2
3
3.5
Coolife Hardside Expandable 28\"
2.5
2
2.5
3.5
Travelers Club Chicago 28\"
2
2
2.5
3
Another absolute top performer in this metric is the Briggs & Riley Baseline Large. We love it because it remains compact and well-balanced no matter how much you pack. Its superior wheels roll smoothly whether you're cruising through baggage claim, strolling down a city sidewalk, or heading for hotel check-in.
On smooth, flat surfaces the Baseline had no problem keeping pace with us, even with only one hand to guide it. Its high-end spinners make easy work of quick turns and tight spaces.
Credit: Jason Wanlass
The rest on our list work reliably well on smooth ground. And when you tilt them up on two wheels, they can also manage cobblestones and even short gravel stretches. Additional models like the Away The Large and the Samsonite Freeform prove that you don't have to spend a fortune on your luggage to get a smooth ride. Both offer double-wheeled spinners that cruise very well.
We absolutely love the Samsonite's upgraded, double-wheeled spinners. The Freeform runs fast and vibration-free.
Credit: Jason Wanlass
If you spend any real time on rough surfaces, you should consider the two-wheeled roller bags. They aren't as responsive and nimble as spinners at the airport since they require wider turns, but they tend to have bigger wheels that fare better in rowdy, uneven terrain.
Lugging tons of gear through downtown Geneva, en route to the Swiss Alps. Although it's much more at home on dirt roads, our ORV Trunk 30 also performed well on city streets.
Credit: Jason Wanlass
Among the duffel rollers in our lineup, the Osprey Sojourn Shuttle 100L is an off-road roller dream, with substantial all-terrain wheels and a selection of grab-and-go load handles that make it among the easiest to handle and load under the most varied conditions. The Eagle Creek ORV is similarly outfitted with a variety of well-placed handles to aid in the transition between asphalt, trail, and vehicle or hotel. You can also haul the Eagle Creek Cargo Hauler XT and the Patagonia Black Hole by their multiple handle options, and the Cargo Hauler XT even offers backpack straps. However, when it comes to transport options, we absolutely loved traveling with the Osprey Daylite Wheeled Duffel 85. Not only is it super lightweight, but it also has large all-terrain wheels, and it can be carried as a duffel or backpack. We feel it's one of the more versatile bags in our lineup.
Thriving in different places and spaces. We loved how easy the Osprey Daylite is to move around. The only thing we didn't like is its lack of multiple exterior handles.
Credit: Jason Wanlass
We spent several weeks in Nepal and Tibet with our The North Face Base Camp Rolling Thunder 28. We fell in love with its smooth ride, sturdy trolley handle, and five easy-to-grab exterior handles. Snagging this bag from the baggage claim carousel is easy peasy.
Cruising the side streets of a small Tibetan town in China and collecting bags in Kathmandu, Nepal. Tons of exterior handles and massive wheels make North Face Base Camp Rolling Thunder a great option for adventure.
Credit: Jason Wanlass
If you're seeking a gentle ride that won't vibrate your arm off when navigating between city sidewalks and cobbled streets, check out the Timbuk2 Copilot. This bag uses skateboard wheels that feature a broad, stable base and a very smooth glide. Also, consider a bag with higher clearance. The Briggs & Riley Baseline is untouchable in this regard among the traditional spinner bags.
Headed downstairs to the check-in counter. This Timbuk2 rolls on skateboard wheels, making it one of the smoothest cruisers on our list.
Credit: Jason Wanlass
Let's face it — there is some terrain that you won't be able to roll any of these bags over. So we paid attention to how hard they are to carry. We appreciate the spinner bags with at least three haul handles — one on the top, another on the bottom, and one on the side. The Briggs & Riley Baseline meets this requirement very well, as do the Travelpro Platinum Elite and the SwissGear Sion. Among the duffels, the Eagle Creek Cargo Hauler has several rugged load handles and lays claim to a set of detachable backpack straps hidden inside a small front zip pocket. The Osprey Sojourn Shuttle, Eagle Creek ORV Trunk, Dakine Split Roller 5L, and Patagonia Black Hole are surrounded by excellent grab handles that can be accessed from nearly every angle.
Crossing over one of many canal bridges as we make our way to the train station.
Some bridges had stairs, but even when fully loaded, the Eagle Creek's handles helped make the journey manageable.
Cruising the back canals of Venice, Italy. The Eagle Creek ORV Trunk 30 can easily handle bumpy cobble and bridges, and it has tons of handles and straps, so picking it up from any angle is a breeze.
Lastly, the Cotopaxi Allpa 65L Roller is compact, lightweight, and easy to transport. It's covered in handles, so a perfectly balanced handgrip is always available for boarding, loading, or jumping a curb. This bag is a little smaller than the other checked luggage on our list, so it maneuvers a lot like a carry-on bag.
Hopping the airport shuttle en-route to Denver. The Cotopaxi Allpa 65L Roller maneuvers well and is easy to throw around when time is of the essence.
Credit: Jason Wanlass
Construction Quality
You need reliable luggage. Once you drop it off at the airport, you have no control over how well it's handled. Then you're going to drag it over rough terrain, pull it up and down flights of stairs, and toss it in and out of vehicles. Zippers, handles, and wheels are typically the most vulnerable points where suitcases may break down. We evaluated the craftsmanship of each case in our lineup and tested them with a minimum of two months of travel.
General Wear and Tear
If you're considering dropping hundreds of dollars on a top-of-the-line model, you should start by looking at the outer material. In general, suitcases are divided into two categories — hard and soft.
A concrete staircase is no match for the Briggs & Riley's ballistic-nylon exterior, full-length bumper rails, and reinforced corners. It breezed through several rounds of tumble tests.
Credit: Jason Wanlass
Counterintuitively, hard cases are generally more susceptible to visible wear and tear than soft-sided options. The hard cases in this review include the Samsonite Freeform, Tumi 19 Degree Extended Trip, Away The Large, Rimowa Check-In, Amazon Basics 30", and the Kenneth Cole Reaction. The first four are made of 100% polycarbonate, a fairly durable plastic, with the Samsonite Freeform boasting a particularly scratch-resistant micro-diamond hardshell exterior. The remaining pair are made of less durable acrylonitrile butadiene styrene (ABS). We particularly loved the toughness of the Away The Large bag. Regardless of the abuse it endured, it was always ready for more. We consider it one of the most rugged hardshells in our lineup.
This video speaks for itself (it's even more fun at full volume). The Away can handle contact. In fact, its very resilient polycarbonate shell almost seems to enjoy it - we certainly did.
Credit: Jason Wanlass
Soft cases stand up better to abuse overall since they can flex with impact. They are more prone to break-ins, though, since they are relatively easy to cut or puncture. The soft-sided bags in our test are made of nylon, polyester, or both. To determine how durable the polyester bags might be, look at the denier or D rating (such as "800D nylon").
The Eagle Creek ORV integrates many materials to make it super durable. 1000-denier polyester construction with reinforced plastic bumpers on all corners of the case adds reinforcement for high abrasion areas.
Credit: Amber King
The Briggs & Riley Baseline and Osprey Sojourn Shuttle both employ ballistic nylon, which was developed during World War II to make flax jackets for airmen. So, it's pretty tough. Since the Osprey Sojourn is more of an adventure bag, we decided to really put it to the test, and we were very happy with its performance. This bag is super rugged and suitable for worldwide travel.
Our tumble tests typically involve pushing our bags down a concrete stairwell. We decided to take this test up a notch or three when we tested the Sojourn Shuttle. A few rocks didn't do much against its very secure exterior.
Credit: Jason Wanlass
The Eagle Creek ORV is suited up in a proprietary and tactically appropriate combination of Helix Poly Twill and Bi-Tech Armor (TPU-coated polyester). Its lighter-weight cousin, the Eagle Creek Cargo Hauler XT, is built of similarly strong Helix Poly Twill and TPU-covered poly. We know less about the construction of the Timbk2 Copilot, reported simply as “nylon and polyester,” yet we've seen it withstand years of use with very little wear. This leads us to believe that even these soft-sided cases and roller duffels in our lineup are built to last.
Testing the Eagle Creek ORV Trunk 30's off-road abilities. This bag is tough, large, and ready for adventure.
Credit: Jason Wanlass
Finally, one of the toughest bags in our lineup is the The North Face Base Camp Rolling Thunder. We lugged this monster all over Korea, Nepal, and Tibet and were thoroughly impressed with its performance. Its shell is made from very dense, recycled 1000-denier polyester. It withstood three weeks of being shoved, tossed, tied, and yanked and never once showed any signs of give. All of our travel did leave a fair amount of scuffs on our North Face (purely cosmetic), but our testing team thought this only made the Rolling Thunder look cooler and added to its legitimacy as a true adventure bag.
Making our way through Tibet, China. The North Face Base Camp Rolling Thunder is built for movement. It's rugged design is perfect for all forms of conventional and unconventional travel.
Credit: Jason Wanlass
Water Resistance
We placed a blue industrial paper towel strip in each of our suitcases (blue because it shows moisture) and then hosed each contender down on full blast for about three minutes, with another three spent targeting the most vulnerable entry and connection points. The external materials of some of the test cases were largely impervious to water under testing, but nearly all suffered from moisture infiltrating at handle joints and through zipper teeth or pull connections, leaving various amounts of water pooled toward the back and bottom of each suitcase, and often in the exterior pockets as well. Any that kept water out of critical areas, like the watertight Timbuk2 Copilot, whose padded front sleeve and liquids pocket remained dry through testing, scored the best overall in this category.
Gearing up for our water testing. We filled each bag with a section of blue industrial paper towel. We picked blue because it shows even the slightest drop of moisture.
Credit: Jason Wanlass
Several of the large rolling duffels in our series — the Eagle Creek ORV, Eagle Creek Cargo Hauler XT, Osprey Sojourn Shuttle, The North Face Base Camp Rolling Thunder, and the Patagonia Black Hole — did relatively well against our simulated downpour. The recessed construction and awning-like fabric flaps help wick water away from vulnerable components, providing the bag with a base amount of protection from the start. Top performers were the Travelpro Platinum Elite, Briggs & Riley Baseline, Rimowa Essential Check-In, and the Tumi 19 Degree Extended Trip. The takeaway? None of the bags in this test suite can offer guarantees, but if you need decent water resistance for your travels, look for hardshells with reinforced zippers or set your eye on options with protected zippers and water-repelling materials.
This timelapse of our water testing shows how we showered our bags side by side. Among the best softshell performers was the Travelpro Platinum Elite.
Credit: Jason Wanlass
Wheels
In general, two-wheeled options use larger wheels that are simpler and often more durable. Four-wheeled models often have smaller wheels with more complex construction, which means there's just more to break. But regardless of their potential break-ability, the four-wheeled spinners, in particular those that are double-wheeled spinners, provide the smoothest, quietest, most worry-free ride. Unfortunately, this type of quality will always cost you more.
It practically walks itself. The Travelpro's self-aligning wheels keep this bag in line, all the time. They are also some of the most durable spinners in our lineup.
Credit: Jason Wanlass
Among our favorite wheels in the test are the skateboard rollers on the Timbuk2 Copilot. If they can stand up to skateboarding, you best believe they can roll your clothes around. They're solid, stable, and easy to change out. We also loved the wheel systems on the Travelpro Platinum Elite, Briggs & Riley Baseline, Tumi 19 Degree Extended Trip, Away The Large, and Rimowa Essential.
Yeah, we actually get excited about suitcase wheels. And, when it comes to the best, the Rimowa's ride was at the top of our list.
Credit: Jason Wanlass
Among the more affordable spinners on our list, we were quite pleased with the Delsey Paris Titanium Hardside 29", Samsonite Freeform Large Spinner, Coolife Hardside Expandable 28", Showkoo Expandable Hardside Set 28", and the Amazon Basics 30" Hardside Spinner. In particular, the Amazon bag offered double-wheeled spinners that had a very smooth ride; however, we are still a little unsure about their overall construction quality. Another less expensive favorite with solid wheels is the SwissGear Sion Softside Expandable Roller 29".
Pulling our SwissGear Sion on two wheels as we rush to check-in. Although small and a little rattly, these wheels are fairly tough and ready for battle.
Credit: Jason Wanlass
Other two-wheeled options that came close include the Osprey Sojourn Shuttle, The North Face Base Camp Rolling Thunder 28, Osprey Daylite Wheeled Duffel, REI Co-op Big Haul Rolling Duffel, and the Eagle Creek ORV. Each has sturdy, oversized wheels that move easily up and over obstacles, with the Osprey Shuttle touting the tallest wheels of all the bags in our review. The Eagle Creek Cargo Hauler XT also has large, treaded wheels, but they are built into a protective wheel housing that significantly reduces the bag's clearance, making it harder to navigate varied terrain and leaving the bag susceptible to damage from catching on objects in motion.
Checking the The North Face Base Camp Rolling Thunder's hefty wheels. These beauties are made for exploring.
Credit: Jason Wanlass
Lastly, we also really loved the cruising ability of the Cotopaxi Allpa 65L Roller. It boasts two independent, oversized, all-terrain wheels that can handle just about any rugged surface but are also refined enough for a smooth ride in the airport or down a city street.
Heading to our hotel in downtown Denver. We loved the Cotopaxi Allpa 65L Roller's hybrid wheels. They ride well on concrete, tile, or dirt.
Credit: Jason Wanlass
Handles
A good handle should retain its strength and shape even under considerable packed weight and average travel use. In our testing, the handles of nearly all cases proved to be impressively resilient during use tests, even up to 50 pounds. Among the burliest are the Osprey Shuttle, Eagle Creek ORV, Travelpro Platinum Elite, Briggs & Riley Baseline, Rimowa Essential, and The North Face Base Camp Rolling Thunder. The rest of the handles jiggled and flexed more substantially under pressure, particularly when fully extended, but still delivered where it counts — in motion.
A good handle that is comfortable and won't blow out under a heavy load is very important to ensure the reliability of your suitcase.
Credit: Amber King
Traveling Up Stairs
One of the worst things you can do to your luggage — and your stairs — is to drag your case up, banging the backside of the case on each step. It's better just to carry your luggage up if you can. If you can't or don't want to, look for models with protective plastic rails that run from the wheels up a large length of the case. These also help protect the bag from general wear and tear when laid to rest or shoved across the ground. Cases like Patagonia Black Hole, The North Face Base Camp Rolling Thunder 8, and Briggs & Riley Baseline all have this feature.
Testing our Rolling Thunder's handles, trolley, and bumper rails - 10 out of 10, highly recommend.
Credit: Jason Wanlass
The Timbuk2 Copilot has an exterior handle housing set up to serve this purpose, but the metal material quickly becomes scratched when dragged along cement or wooden edges. The Eagle Creek ORV and Cargo Hauler XT also do reasonably well, but they primarily rely on their oversized wheels to keep the bag from banging destructively up stairwells in transit.
Hanging in there as we heave our Sion Softside up the never-ending staircase of doom. Although it isn't ideal to lift a suitcase by its trolley, sometimes you gotta do what you gotta do. We were pleasantly surprised with this bag's pull handle. It's strong and sturdy.
Credit: Jason Wanlass
When it comes to stairs and other rough terrain, we expect the The North Face Base Camp Rolling Thunder, Eagle Creek ORV, Osprey Sojourn Shuttle, REI Co-op Big Haul Rolling Duffel, and Cotopaxi Allpa Roller to stand up the best over time. They all have super burly outer materials with handles and wheels that are durable, well-clearanced, and easy to change out. We also expect the Briggs & Riley Baseline to last. If durability and reliability are what you seek, these are our favorites. Other all-around well-built options include the Timbuk2 Copilot, Away The Large, Eagle Creek Cargo Hauler, and Patagonia Black Hole.
Denver baggage claim. Although thinner than our beefier adventure bags, the Cotopaxi Allpa's shell is still rugged enough for basic travel. Its wheels, handles, and zippers are also top-notch.
Credit: Jason Wanlass
Design and Functionality
Here, we considered the overall looks and the versatility of each bag. Because of the subjective nature of style, we polled as many people as possible and considered as many viewpoints as possible. Since luggage is such an investment, we mostly gave points for looks we thought would last. We considered the variety of places each is well-suited to and would both do and look at home in. We tested every feature for usability and gauged how convenient each aspect is.
When you approach airport baggage claim, you usually spy a sea of black roller bags, all with similar designs, duplicated in various aspects across many brands. But there are others that we think look better and will certainly be easier to pick out at the airport.
In an endless sea of luggage design and function, sometimes buying the right one just comes down to preference. Often, hardshells have the most trendy styles.
Credit: Jason Wanlass
Hard cases seem to be a favorite among the fashion-forward, and the Tumi 19 Degree Extended Trip and Rimowa Essential spinner bags don't disappoint — but their price tags just might. They both offer very striking patterns and a chic design to catch the eye of anyone looking to stand out at baggage claim. You'll pay extra for their looks, but if style is important for your travel aesthetic, you won't be disappointed with either of these options.
Our Tumi's wavy shell vibed perfectly with the Salt Lake City Airport artistic interior. Then again, it pretty much stood out wherever we took it.
Sometimes you just look good, and you know it. Yeah, that's just how the Rimowa rolls.
Hardshells are often fan favorites for having the most appealing designs.
The Away The Large and the Samsonite Freeform also stand out as stylish, modern options, appealing to everyone who tested it. Specifically, the Away The Large's matte finish and choice of contemporary color palettes allow you to express yourself. The Travelpro Platinum Elite is a good-looking soft-sided bag that also has a ton of organizational features designed for urban exploration. The Briggs & Riley Baseline isn't far behind, with a sleek, professional design that isn't flashy but just looks good. Its pockets and organization are similarly designed for business travel or heading to a black-tie event.
Heading for the Arrival/Departure board in style with our Away The Large.
Credit: Jason Wanlass
The North Face Base Camp Rolling Thunder has a very appealing sporty/adventure vibe and was an instant crowd-pleaser, as was the REI Co-op Big Haul. The Osprey Daylite Wheeled Duffel boasts a sleek, lightweight design, and the Timbuk2 Copilot is a lot less flashy, but its compact shape and pulled-together style always made us feel polished. The Patagonia Black Hole isn't winning our hearts for its style, but as a cavernous roller duffel, it allows you to put together your own customized packing system or simply stuff everything in all at once — you decide.
Cruising downtown Kathmandu, Nepal, looking for our morning cappuccino before heading out.
Making use of The North Face Base Camp Rolling Thunder as we wait to walk across the Nepal-Tibet border.
Maxed out: Our final day in Tibet. We have more souvenirs than clothing, but our Rolling Thunder was still able to hold it all -- with two pounds to spare.
The North Face Base Camp Rolling Thunder 28 is as stylish as it is functional, making it one of our favorite adventure bags.
Still, other contenders offer an outdoorsy, casual look, including the Dakine Split Roller, Eagle Creek Cargo Hauler XT, Osprey Shuttle, and the Cotopaxi Allpa Roller. In particular, we love the Cotopaxi Allpa for its unique, colorful, patchwork design. Both brand-name lovers and shoppers who aren't that picky will fall in love with this stylish and functional bag. It was certainly a fan favorite in our group of testers.
Looking good in the hustle and bustle of the mile-high Denver International Airport.
An early Sunday morning on the streets of downtown Denver.
A shot of our Cotopaxi Allpa with its companion carry-on as we shuttle to long-term parking.
The Cotopaxi Allpa 65L Roller was a crowd favorite and is as equally good lookin' and user-friendly.
The most technical and tactical-looking bag in this review is the Eagle Creek ORV. This soft-sided option isn't fashionable in an urban city sense, looking instead like the bag you'll take on your next big expedition. However, we still love its organization and functionality, and it's right at home, bumping down a dirt road to our next camping site. However, if forced to choose between the Eagle Creek and the REI Co-op Big Haul, many of our testers would choose the REI model. It has a sleeker look, a simpler packing system, and lots of extra stylish reinforcements.
Showing off our REI Big Haul Duffel from a recent hiking trip to Maine. It has a great look and is a dream for hauling gear.
Credit: Jason Wanlass
Conclusion
There is seemingly no end to the luggage options available to you today. In this review, we take a critical look at some of the best available options. Remember to start by deciding if a roller or a spinner bag will be best for your travel purposes. Then, figure out your budget and think about if there are any “must-have” features you need. We hope this review helps you narrow down the details to find the luggage that best fits your travel plans.
Calling it a day. And yes, we got a lot of confused looks.
