Reviews You Can Rely On

The Best 10 Softshell Jackets of 2024

We put top softshell jackets from brands like Patagonia, Arc'teryx, Outdoor Research, Rab, and others through the test on every kind of terrain and through all possible weather possible
gearlab tested logo
Best Softshell Jacket Review
Credit: Kate Pitts

Our Top Picks

By Zach Lovell, Kate Pitts, Mary Witlacil, and Ryan Huetter  ⋅  Nov 13, 2024

The Best Softshell Jackets for 2024


Fans of year-round adventure activities like hiking, climbing, running, or skiing are always on the hunt for the unicorn of all layers: breathable weather protection. The softshell jacket was made to fill this hole, and it has been our ongoing mission for over a decade to help you hone in on the very best options to meet your specific outfitting needs. We've tasked our dedicated team of gear experts to scour the market for softshell jackets and then rigorously test the top sellers among them to ensure you can easily find the perfect fit. From the backcountry trails and snowy peaks of Colorado to remote crags and glacial valleys between the Pacific Northwest and the Sierra Nevada, we've dedicated thousands of hours thoroughly assessing nearly 150 jackets across a wide variety of activities and conditions and capturing our findings to help narrow our list to the best softshell jackets among them. Although you won't find the highest level of weather resistance in a softshell, these layers can be sufficient to keep you dry in brief, light-to-moderate conditions. More importantly, they integrate features meant to maximize your comfort during athletic pursuits once the sweat picks up. Below, you'll find an overview of our top picks from both women's and men's reviews, including our favorites overall to the lightest, most packable, and easy-to-move-in models available and the most budget-friendly across the lot.

Softshell jackets are often perceived as two-in-one layers, a garment that strives to marry the best features from different types of jackets into a single multi-purpose option. The final result is generally suitable for light rain, wind, and dry snow, but rarely are these the best choices for severe weather. If you anticipate heavy rain and strong winds, you might want to consider a more technical hardshell jacket for men or a women's hardshell jacket. If you're seeking a lighter duty layer, check out our articles on men's best wind breaker jackets and best wind breaker jackets for women.

Related: Top Softshell Jackets for Women
Related: Best Softshell Jackets for Men


Men's Best Overall Softshell Jacket


Arc'teryx Gamma Hoody


82
OVERALL
SCORE
  • Weather Protection 9.0
  • Breathability 8.5
  • Mobility 7.5
  • Weight 6.9
  • Versatility 8.5
REASONS TO BUY
Versatile and high-performing
Decent protection in various conditions
Constructed with sturdy materials
REASONS TO AVOID
Slim fit less ideal for some
Lacks chest pocket on exterior
Pricey
SPECIFICATIONS
Number of Pockets 2 exterior hand zip, 1 interior chest zip
Measured Weight (Size) 17.3 oz (small)
Breathability Test (In-Use Absorption) 26 sq in
Warmth Test 26.01 min
Water Retention Test (1-Min Soak) 39 sq in

No matter what activities you've got planned, be it climbing, hiking, backcountry skiing, or boating on a windy day, our testers unanimously agree the Arc'teryx Gamma Hoody makes a great choice when selecting a layer to carry along. It is the perfect all-arounder, delivering an exceptionally balanced performance between weather protection and breathability, including decent ventilation during high-output days and some resistance to cold or rain when required. This layer also provides excellent comfort and is easy to layer, especially if adding another jacket over the top. While it may not be the ideal outer layer in severe storms, its signature StormHood and adjustable hem can help shield you if an unexpected mild storm hits by surprise. Testers also appreciated the aesthetic appeal of this piece, featuring Arc'teryx's iconic panels that lend it a sleek, tailored style.

The slim, more athletic cut of the Arc'teryx Gamma Hoody may not suit everyone. Its design facilitates easy movement while also reducing the chance of fabric bunching, but it is a fit that won't work for every shopper. Some may prefer to size up, if between sizes, or if looking to accommodate more layers underneath comfortably. For those seeking a looser fit with enhanced weather protection, the Rab Kinetic 2.0 is an excellent option worth considering. Another drawback of the Gamma is the absence of a chest pocket at the exterior, which many testers prefer for easy access to their phones. Although the interior pocket at the chest may protect better, in theory, it can be cumbersome to unzip the jacket frequently and create more opportunities for accidental drops in the process. If this is important to you, the Patagonia R2 TechFace Hoody has got you covered. Although the Gamma Hoody comes at a higher price point than some alternatives, many users find its value easily justifies the investment. Ultimately, the Arc'teryx Gamma Hoody stands out as a versatile softshell that is well-suited for year-round use.

Read more: Arc'Teryx Gamma Hoody Review

Which Gamma Model is Right for You?
The Arc'teryx Gamma line has three different options that can be confusing to sift through. This model, the Gamma Hoody, is the midweight option that blends weather resistance and breathability and serves as an all-arounder for varied conditions. The lightest version in the series is the Gamma Lightweight Hoody, which is excellent when it comes to breathability but will have even less weather protection than its heavier sibling. The best warmth and water protection are going to come from the heaviest option in the collection, the Gamma MX, which is also the least breathable.

We greatly appreciated the performance of the Arc'teryx Gamma Hoody, which delivers all around, though its slimmer fit may be trickier to size.
Credit: Syd Knadler

Best Overall Women's Softshell Jacket


Arc'teryx Gamma Hoody - Women's


86
OVERALL
SCORE
  • Weather Protection 9.5
  • Breathability 9.0
  • Mobility 8.0
  • Weight 6.0
  • Versatility 9.0
REASONS TO BUY
Freeing mobility
Resistant to wind
Decent breathability
Road-worthy durability
Comfy lining
Effective hood fits over helmets
REASONS TO AVOID
Relatively heavier
Price strains the wallet
SPECIFICATIONS
Number of Pockets 2 exterior zip hand
Measured Weight (Size: XS) 15.05 oz
Breathability Test (In-Use Absorption) 18 sq in
Warmth Test 26.57 min
Air Dry Test (1-Min Soak to Dry) 1.5 min

The Women's Arc'Teryx Gamma Hoody is celebrated for its outstanding performance across most metrics, achieving an impressive balance between technical features, comfort, breathability, and storm protection, and earning high praise from our testing team. During strenuous activities in cooler weather, we found it remained breathable while still providing superb wind resistance and decent water repellency. We were impressed by the mobility the Wee Burley fabric allowed for, alongside its abrasion-resistant and durable construction. Additionally, testers liked the flattering silhouette of the Gamma Hoody for in-town objectives and felt the many practical elements in the design, like the Napoleon-style harness-compatible pockets, the mesh lining, and a two-way helmet-compatible cinched hood, were smart features to ensure a great fit and superb ventilation for hikes, climbs, or ski tours.

The Gamma Hoody excels in many areas, but its higher price may deter some buyers. Designed for cooler alpine conditions, its durable construction results in a heavier feel compared to other active shells reviewed. The fixed cuffs could also be a consideration, depending on your preference for glove styles. For those wanting a softshell with adjustable cuffs and improved water resistance, the Rab Kinetic 2.0 may be more suitable. Alternatively, the Arc'teryx Gamma Lightweight Hoody for women offers greater breathability and mobility when headed out into warmer conditions. At the end of the day, the Gamma Hoody is an exceptional option for those wanting a softshell that can do it all.

Read more: Arc'teryx Gamma Hoody for Women Review

The Arc'teryx Gamma Hoody was a favorite among our testers of both genders for its fit, adjustability, and breathability.
Credit: Kate Pitts

Men's Best Bang for the Buck


Rab Borealis


79
OVERALL
SCORE
  • Weather Protection 5.0
  • Breathability 9.5
  • Mobility 9.0
  • Weight 8.8
  • Versatility 8.0
REASONS TO BUY
Superior breathability
Well-fitting option
Excellent weight
Quick to dry
REASONS TO AVOID
Limited water resistance
Little adjustability
SPECIFICATIONS
Number of Pockets 2 exterior chest zip
Measured Weight (Size) 9.7 oz (medium)
Breathability Test (In-Use Absorption) 18 sq in
Warmth Test 21.55 min
Water Retention Test (1-Min Soak) 340 sq in

The Rab Borealis is a top-performing, lightweight softshell available at a more accessible price than many premium alternatives. Our testers favored it for its outstanding breathability, thanks to Rab's Matrix fabric, which kept us comfortable on even high-output missions. On warmer outings or during high-intensity activities, the chest pockets can be unzipped to reveal mesh backs that produce effective ventilation, allowing us to keep the layer on throughout the entire day, even when things heat up. The Borealis achieves an impressive fit, a balance between freedom of movement and minimal bunching, whether you're using a harness or carrying a backpack, making it suitable for many varied activities. Its minimalist design also provides a sleek look for casual outings, enabling a smooth transition from the trail to dinner events. In short, this affordably priced jacket is a must-have if you're in search of a respectably lightweight, breathable softshell.

The Rab Borealis falls short in terms of water resistance, leaving our testers damp during field and shower testing. However, given its softshell classification and lightweight single-weave fabric construction, these results were expected. Fortunately, we noted quick drying times both in controlled settings and real-world conditions. This means if you do get soaked in a storm, you can anticipate drying out in the field with speed. Also, the jacket only offers adjustability at the hem, so if it doesn't fit well in the sleeves or hood, you're out of luck. For those seeking better water resistance and more features in their next softshell, consider the Rab Kinetic 2.0. Alternatively, if breathability is your primary concern, the Arc'teryx Gamma Lightweight Hoody presents another excellent lightweight option with additional hood adjustability. Despite some limitations, the Rab Borealis provides remarkable value in a compact, easy-to-carry package and is suitable for outings of virtually any shape or size, as long as you bring additional layers on cold or wet days.

Read more: Rab Borealis Review

We loved the excellent fit of the Rab Borealis, offering a slim aesthetic without reducing mobility.
Credit: Zach Lovell

Women's Best Bang for the Buck


Rab Borealis - Women's


83
OVERALL
SCORE
  • Weather Protection 5.5
  • Breathability 10.0
  • Mobility 9.5
  • Weight 9.0
  • Versatility 7.5
REASONS TO BUY
Exceptional value
Hood fits under and over the helmet
Top-tier mobility
Lightweight construction
Pocket doubles as a stuff sack
Effective pockets for ventilation
REASONS TO AVOID
Subpar water resistance
Requires more layers for optimal protection
SPECIFICATIONS
Number of Pockets 2 exterior zip chest
Measured Weight (Size: XS) 7.75 oz
Breathability Test (In-Use Absorption) 13 sq in
Warmth Test 22.23 min
Air Dry Test (1-Min Soak to Dry) 20,2 min

The Rab Borealis jacket is a well-priced softshell that boasts great ventilation, movement, and wind resistance. It stands out as one of the most breathable jackets in our collection, effectively serving as both a sun and wind shirt for various weather conditions. With impressive features for its price, including a pocket that converts into a stuff sack, it allows you to easily clip the jacket to your harness or keep it accessible in your daypack. Our testers loved its ultra-stretchy fabric, which felt almost weightless during trailside yoga and provided exceptional freedom of movement for climbing. Although it lacks significant water resistance, it dries quickly and does a great job shielding your skin from harmful sun exposure without roasting you otherwise.

While the Borealis is an excellent jacket overall, there are a few drawbacks. Its water resistance is below average compared to other models we tested, and it completely wetted out during our shower test. Nonetheless, it dries rapidly and offers lightweight, breathable protection against wind and UV rays. If you require more robust rain protection, consider the women's version of the Rab Kinetic 2.0, which provides greater storm resistance while maintaining a high degree of mobility. For those prioritizing breathability, the Arc'teryx Gamma Lightweight Hoody is a fantastic alternative with added hood adjustability. Despite some limitations, the Rab Borealis delivers outstanding value in a lightweight design and is perfect for all-day wear.

Read more: Rab Borealis for Women Review

No matter where and when we used it, our testers loved the freedom of movement the Rab Borealis offered, even if there weren't extraordinary amounts of warmth or weather protection to pair with it.
Credit: Kate Pitts

Men's Best for Wet Weather


Rab Kinetic 2.0


80
OVERALL
SCORE
  • Weather Protection 9.0
  • Breathability 7.5
  • Mobility 7.5
  • Weight 8.3
  • Versatility 7.5
REASONS TO BUY
Outstanding water-resistance
Decent breathability relative to weather protection
Wide range of motion
REASONS TO AVOID
Lacks a chest pocket
Hood on the smaller side
Potential for fabric bunching
SPECIFICATIONS
Number of Pockets 2 exterior hand zip
Measured Weight (Size) 11.6 oz (medium)
Breathability Test (In-Use Absorption) 30 sq in
Warmth Test 29.25 min
Water Retention Test (1-Min Soak) 10 sq in

The Rab Kinetic 2.0 ranks among the best weather-resistant softshells on the market today. Rab has put a great deal of effort into the Kinetic's design, and the latest version features improved breathability over previous iterations. In both real-world scenarios and controlled shower tests, the jacket performed exceptionally well, allowing minimal moisture penetration during short storms. We also appreciated its slightly looser cut, which offers a broad range of motion, along with adjustable hems and arms for a more customized fit. Our testers grew increasingly confident using the Kinetic 2.0 as their primary outer layer on several multi-day trips, as long as the weather forecast called for minimal precipitation.

While the Kinetic 2.0 boasts useful features, we would have preferred the inclusion of a chest pocket. Unlike some models that offer only an interior chest pocket (a frustration unto itself), this jacket lacks one entirely, necessitating users to store their phones or other devices in their pants or within another layer. When wearing a backpack with a hip strap or harness that can obstruct the waist pockets, this proves a headache. We hope this is a design decision Rab will reconsider with future design updates. The Marmot ROM Infinium Hoody is an excellent alternative for weather resistance and includes a chest pocket if that's a deal breaker. Additionally, we found some excess fabric around the abdomen and wrists, leading to unwanted bunching. Lastly, we would have liked the option of an over-helmet hood for better weather protection, as the under-helmet design is less effective. The Marmot ROM also addresses this concern, as does our team's overall favorite, the Gamma Hoody. So, if the hood fit is a top consideration, we'd point you in either direction. Despite these minor drawbacks, the Kinetic 2.0 is a top-tier softshell that is worth your investment, especially if you frequently encounter damp conditions.

Read more: Rab Kinetic 2.0 Review

The Rab Kinetic 2.0 boasts exceptional mobility plus water resistance, making for a particularly handy garment in variable environments.
Credit: Zach Lovell

Women's Best for Wet Weather


Rab Kinetic 2.0 - Women's


82
OVERALL
SCORE
  • Weather Protection 9.0
  • Breathability 7.5
  • Mobility 8.0
  • Weight 8.0
  • Versatility 8.0
REASONS TO BUY
All weather performance
Stretchy and full ape index mobility
Plush and breathable fabric
Waterproofed fabric and taped seams
Highly wind resistant and warm
REASONS TO AVOID
Zipper line can leak more quickly
No clipping feature for your harness
Lacks built-in stow-away pocket
SPECIFICATIONS
Number of Pockets 2 exterior zip hand
Measured Weight (Size: XS) 9.30 oz
Breathability Test (In-Use Absorption) 19 sq in
Warmth Test 28.57 min
Air Dry Test (1-Min Soak to Dry) 15.2 min

When unpredictable weather strikes, you need a reliable jacket like the Rab Kinetic 2.0. This versatile softshell offers exceptional breathability while providing wet weather protection closer to what we'd expect to see from a hardshell. Ideal for activities such as alpine climbing, sea kayaking, or hiking, this option is perfect for those adventuring in rainy climates or in areas prone to consistent afternoon thunderstorms. Its snug hood design effectively shields your face from harsh winds and rain, making it a smart addition to your outdoor gear.

While the Kinetic 2.0 excels in resisting water and wind, it may not be the most packable choice for technical activities like rock climbing or paddling, where space and stowing options can be crucial. If you prefer a more compact design with integrated easy-pack tools, consider the Black Diamond Alpine Start or Rab Borealis, both of which store into one of their own pockets and feature attachment loops for convenient attaching to your pack or belt during adventures.

Read more: Rab Kinetic 2.0 for Women Review

The Rab Kinetic 2.0 creates a decent seal around the head for excellent weather protection when things get stormy.
Credit: Kate Pitts

Men's Best for Cold Weather


Patagonia R2 TechFace Hoody


78
OVERALL
SCORE
  • Weather Protection 9.5
  • Breathability 6.5
  • Mobility 8.0
  • Weight 6.9
  • Versatility 6.5
REASONS TO BUY
Top-scoring water-resistance
Impressive breathability-to-warmth ratio
A favorite for comfort
REASONS TO AVOID
Less optimal for technical use
Limited adjustability
SPECIFICATIONS
Number of Pockets 2 exterior chest zip, 2 exterior hand zip, 2 interior drop-in
Measured Weight (Size) 17.5 oz (medium)
Breathability Test (In-Use Absorption) 35 sq in
Warmth Test 30.25 min
Water Retention Test (1-Min Soak) 4 sq in

The Patagonia R2 TechFace Hoody is a standout choice for those seeking warmth and water resistance, making it ideal for cooler temperatures and transitional seasons. As a heavier-weight softshell, its heat retention capabilities were impressive, but what truly surprised us was its breathability when considering its jacket class. The fleece-lined interior features a grid pattern that effectively channels moisture to the nylon outer layer, allowing testers to wear this jacket for extended periods while backpacking or climbing. The interior fleece liner also delivers exceptional next-to-skin comfort, making it a particularly inviting jacket to wear even around town. During our shower test, the DWR-treated nylon shell kept us nearly dry even under full blast, showcasing its effectiveness for limited exposure to even heavy rain. Whether you're hanging out in town or venturing into the mountains, the R2 should be on your shortlist if you're looking for a warmer softshell.

The Patagonia R2 TechFace Hoody does lack adjustability features like Velcro or drawstrings in the hem, hood, and cuffs, which may affect fit for some users. While the elastic bindings may work for some, those seeking more customization might consider the Arc'teryx Gamma MX Hoody, which offers a similarly warm body but with a slimmer cut and greater adjustability for technical activities like climbing or skiing. If these limitations on fit aren't deal breakers for you, the Patagonia R2 remains an outstanding option for chilly weather, especially when rain or snow is in the forecast. Or, if you plan to dress in layers and care more about water resistance and having fit adjustment options than you do built-in warmth, the Rab Kinetic 2.0 will serve you well.

Read more: Patagonia R2 Techface Review

We loved the breathability of the Patagonia R2 TechFace Hoody, with a grid-patterned fleece guiding moisture away from the body. The mobility was also particularly freeing.
Credit: Zach Lovell

Women's Best for Cold Weather


Patagonia R1 CrossStrata Hoody - Women's


77
OVERALL
SCORE
  • Weather Protection 8.0
  • Breathability 8.0
  • Mobility 7.0
  • Weight 8.0
  • Versatility 7.5
REASONS TO BUY
Great temperature regulation
Effective pockets design
Comfy and soft fleece lining
Insulation offers great breathability
Stretchy fabric and construction
REASONS TO AVOID
Lacks much adjustability
Specific fit may not work for all
SPECIFICATIONS
Number of Pockets 2 exterior hand, 1 exterior chest zip, 1 exterior chest snap
Measured Weight (Size: XS) 10.80 oz
Breathability Test (In-Use Absorption) 22 sq in
Warmth Test 30.33 min
Air Dry Test (1-Min Soak to Dry) 7.2 min

The Patagonia R1 CrossStrata Hoody impressed us with its innovative design, striking an exceptional balance between cozy warmth, ventilation, weather protection, and mobility in a compact, easy-to-pack-and-carry size. This versatile layer is perfect for women who play in the mountains, providing breathability during peak ascents just as it will keep the chill at bay on windy days spent paddling alpine lakes. Managing temperature during high-intensity activities can be challenging, but this hoody excels in regulating warmth on cooler days. Given the unpredictable nature of mountain weather, which can shift from sunny to stormy in moments, this layer is an excellent choice for adapting to sudden changes. The soft fleece lining feels luxurious against the skin, while the durable outer fabric ensures you can transition seamlessly from cozy moments by the campfire to more rugged activities at the crag.

While the CrossStrata Hoody retains warmth and resists wind effectively, it should not be relied upon as your sole insulating layer in extremely cold conditions. For a more robust option that provides better storm protection, consider the Arc'teryx Gamma Hoody - Women's. Or, if weather protection is a top concern but you plan to build in your own warm, insulating layers when needed, the Rab Kinetic 2.0 is a great choice to wear over the top. For those who don't love a slim fit, the Marmot '96 Active Anorak presents a stylish yet roomy alternative designed to fit comfortably over insulating layers and still offer excellent wind and rain resistance.

Read more: Patagonia R1 CrossStrata Hoody Review

The Patagonia R1 CrossStrata Hoody offers weather protection and an excellent range of motion, plus far better warmth retention than most in its class.
Credit: Kate Pitts

Men's Best Lightweight Option


Black Diamond Alpine Start Hoody


76
OVERALL
SCORE
  • Weather Protection 5.5
  • Breathability 8.5
  • Mobility 8.5
  • Weight 9.5
  • Versatility 6.5
REASONS TO BUY
Incredibly low weight
Breathes very well
Packs into pocket
Wonderful freedom of movement
REASONS TO AVOID
Some excess fabric bunches
Only offers a single pocket
Less heat retention than some
SPECIFICATIONS
Number of Pockets 1 exterior chest zip
Measured Weight (Size) 6.9 oz (medium)
Breathability Test (In-Use Absorption) 23 sq in
Warmth Test 21.08 min
Water Retention Test (1-Min Soak) 210 sq in

The Black Diamond Alpine Start Hoody is an impressively lightweight option that makes it easy to justify bringing along on almost any outdoor adventure. As one of the lightest softshells available, it feels almost nonexistent when worn and is easily stowed in a harness or backpack. Although this layer isn't designed for heavy rain, it exceeds expectations in terms of water resistance and effectively shields against wind. We appreciated the exceptional mobility it provided at a featherlight weight, allowing us to move freely in any position required by our activities and offering just enough protection from the elements to keep us outdoors and comfortable under frequently changing skies.

The Alpine Start does not provide much warmth, which is typical for such a minimalist design. So, while it helps block wind on alpine ridges or mountainous hikes, our testers are quick to point out that an additional layer is necessary when temperatures drop significantly. Its baggier fit can also lead to some fabric bunching around the wrists and abdomen. Those seeking a more athletic cut might prefer the Rab Borealis even at its slightly heavier weight. Ultimately, Black Diamond's Alpine Start Hoody is an outstanding choice in the ultralight category and should be included in your pack if minimizing weight is a priority and you want something that breathes and moves with ease.

Read more: Black Diamond Alpine Start Hoody Review

Black Diamond's Alpine Start Hoody is easy to always keep with you as the just-in-case layer for wind, cooler temps, or light rain.
Credit: Syd Knadler

Women's Favorite Lightweight


Arc'teryx Gamma Lightweight Hoody - Women's


85
OVERALL
SCORE
  • Weather Protection 7.5
  • Breathability 9.5
  • Mobility 8.5
  • Weight 8.5
  • Versatility 9.0
REASONS TO BUY
Flexible and lightweight material
Great balance of athletic cut and mobility
Abrasion resistance
Decent versatility
REASONS TO AVOID
Lacks wrist adjustability
Not as weather resistant as others
Expensive
SPECIFICATIONS
Number of Pockets 2 exterior zip hand
Measured Weight (Size: XS) 8.60 oz
Breathability Test (In-Use Absorption) 14 sq in
Warmth Test 22.17 min
Air Dry Test (1-Min Soak to Dry) 2.6 min

Weighing in at just half a pound, the Arc'teryx Gamma Lightweight Hoody is a nimble softshell that delivers decent wind and weather protection relative to its weight. It outperforms other lightweight options with superior weather resistance and features a rain-blocking, helmet-compatible hood. Breathable enough to serve as a sleek sun shirt during fast packing, the Fortius™ 1.0 softshell fabric stretches, breathes, and provides UPF 40+ protection. Its durable construction holds up well during climbs while effectively blocking wind chill. As the lightest jacket in the Gamma line, it's our go-to choice for warmer seasons or when tackling higher output activities.

While the Gamma Lightweight Hoody excels in breathability and offers solid protection against wind and high UV exposure, it is not as weather-resistant as the heavier Arc'teryx models nor many of the other softshells in our lineup. It may allow water to seep through during prolonged exposure, so be prepared to reach for your rain gear when necessary. If you prefer an athletic fit with more storm resistance, consider the heavier Arc'Teryx Gamma Hoody, or choose the Kinetic 2.0 for better performance in wet conditions. If you want to shave even a couple more ounces off your pack weight and you are game to sacrifice weather protection for easy mobility and great ventilation, the Black Diamond Alpine Start Hoody is another featherlight softshell that deserves a look.

Read more: Arc'teryx Gamma Lightweight Hoody for Women Review

We greatly appreciated the freedom of movement afforded by the Gamma Lightweight Hoody, also offering exceptional breathability.
Credit: Kate Pitts


How We Test Softshell Jackets


Our softshell testing starts just like every category at GearLab, with thorough market research to curate the best possible lineup. Once we run through an in-depth selection process, we embark on rigorous and detailed testing of each product. First, we purchase every jacket ourselves to minimize bias. Next, we evaluate all aspects of the softshells, not just through extensive field trials but also by conducting objective testing in a controlled “lab” setting to enhance our findings with measurable data. Once complete, we synthesize and analyze the information collected to deliver comprehensive and trustworthy reviews you can rely on.

We assessed the performance of these softshell jackets in 5 key metrics:
  • Weather Protection
  • Breathability
  • Mobility
  • Weighting
  • Versatility

softshell jacket - we tested every softshell jacket in our review in real world...
We tested every softshell jacket in our review in real world environments, ensuring our testing process was as thorough as possible.
Credit: Kate Pitts

Why Trust GearLab


Our outdoors gear experts are led by wilderness guide Kate Pitts and IFMGA Mountain Guide Zach Lovell. For over a decade, Kate served as a backcountry ranger, educator, and search and rescue professional with the National Park Service in Rocky Mountain National Park, Bryce Canyon, Yosemite, Grand Canyon, and Haleakala. Now a wilderness guide and yoga instructor in Yosemite, she starts her mornings on the mat before embarking on adventures like climbing, ultralight backpacking, or scuba diving. She relies on softshell jackets on a daily basis, whether ascending a windy granite dome in Tuolumne or scrambling a high-alpine ridge.

Our testers are experts in their respective outdoors sports.
Our testers are experts in their respective outdoors sports.
Our review team spends countless hours in the great outdoors, making...
Our review team spends countless hours in the great outdoors, making them the ideal athletes to examine softshell jackets.
Our gear reviewers are experts in a variety of outdoor sports, allowing them to test softshell jackets in various settings.

Zach climbs, skis, and guides all over the world, from the arid deserts of the American West to the glaciated peaks of the European Alps. Undoubtedly, his favorite layer is the softshell jacket, which he consistently packs for every climb, ski tour, or hike throughout the year. This versatile garment is essential for Zach, as it provides the right balance of protection and comfort in diverse conditions. Whether facing chilly winds or unexpected weather changes, he relies on his softshell jacket to keep him comfortable and agile in mountainous environments.

Our gear reviewers have taken these softshell jackets far and wide...
Our gear reviewers have taken these softshell jackets far and wide, to some of the largest alpine terrain in the world.
Our review team ensured each jacket was pushed in harsh environments.
Our review team ensured each jacket was pushed in harsh environments.
Our GearLab team has taken softshell jackets all over the world, from the Himalayas to Patagonia.

The softshell review team also includes Mary Witlacil and Ryan Huetter. Mary is a passionate outdoors enthusiast who particularly enjoys alpine climbing in California and Colorado. When she's not rock climbing, you can find her swinging ice tools, scaling mountains, backpacking, cycling, or simply enjoying the views. After college, Ryan moved from the Pacific Northwest to California's Sierra Nevada and has since climbed globally, including over 20 big wall routes in Yosemite and Fitz Roy in Patagonia. Softshell jackets are an essential part of every tester's gear, a reliable accessory no matter what adventure lies ahead.

Our GearLab team has a keen eye for detail, carefully analyzing...
Our GearLab team has a keen eye for detail, carefully analyzing every product's performance during weeks of testing.
Every reviewer took detailed notes every step of the testing process.
Every reviewer took detailed notes every step of the testing process.
What it looks like when a group of detail-oriented people turns their keen eyes to softshell jackets for several weeks of intense testing aimed at delivering comprehensive, comparative insights and useful results.

How to Pick the Best Softshell Jacket for You


Today, there are various types of softshell jackets available, ranging from minimalist windbreakers to insulated options that feel like two jackets combined into one. The first step in your shopping journey is to determine which type of softshell suits your needs best. We'll begin by discussing layering considerations before exploring the design trade-offs you should keep in mind before making a purchase.

softshell jacket - there are many types of softshell jackets available today, but rest...
There are many types of softshell jackets available today, but rest easy knowing there's the right option for you and your needs.
Credit: Zach Lovell

Men's Softshell Jackets


We conducted a thorough and exhaustive review of men's softshell jackets. The following chart summarizes our overall findings, identifying the best softshell options for men.


Women's Softshell Jackets


Our women's review team took on the challenge of honing in on the best softshell jackets for women. The chart below shows the final scores, summarizing which models are considered the top performers among softshell options for women.


How to Incorporate Layers with Softshells


Softshell jackets are versatile in their layering applications, with choices varying based on individual preferences and intended use. Generally, layering decisions are influenced by four key factors: breathability, weather protection, warmth, and fit or cut. Slimmer-fitting jackets are typically worn closer to base layers, while looser options are often used as outer layers. More breathable softshells are best worn near the skin, with options that ventilate less, serving as outer layers.

softshell jacket - there are a variety of ways to layer a softshell jacket, some...
There are a variety of ways to layer a softshell jacket, some options like the Arcteryx Gamma Lightweight Hoody are slimmer fitting and best worn closer to the base layers.
Credit: Zach Lovell

Warmth, usually provided by fleece insulation, is generally maximized when worn close to the body, though some may prefer a different approach. Weather protection is ideally placed on the outermost layer, but it's important to note that softshells have limitations compared to hardshells in severe weather conditions. In inclement weather, a hardshell should always be worn over a softshell for optimal protection.

softshell jacket - looser fitting and more weather-resistant softshells are better when...
Looser fitting and more weather-resistant softshells are better when worn as an outermost layer, like the Patagonia Dirt Roamer, which is perfect for logging miles on a mountain bike.
Credit: Zach Lovell

Water Resistance, Warmth, and Breathability


When a garment is more breathable, we often find, as a general rule, that it is also less weather-resistant or warm. No matter the marketing claims tossed about, this is inevitably true. Even on high-end garments with increased weather resistance, waterproofing, or insulation features, we will expect to see some reduction in breathability to match. Imagine wearing a trash bag as a jacket. You may find it effectively keeps moisture off your inner layers, which is great and exactly what you want. But if you start moving in that trashbag and begin to sweat, you will soon find this moisture has nowhere to go and sits against your skin, creating a clammy feeling and/or wetting any absorbent layers from the inside out. If you decide to up the warmth of your outfit by donning a secondary insulating layer inside your waterproof trash bag, these trapped sweat levels will only go up. It quickly becomes apparent why so many outdoor athletes seek garments with high-performance breathability. It can get hot and sticky in there quickly. Additionally, once you are wet, it's very easy to get cold if your layer does not dry quickly. Your breathability needs are important assessments to make when determining the comfort and functionality of any jacket up for consideration.

softshell jacket - options without insulation are likely to dry more quickly than...
Options without insulation are likely to dry more quickly than jackets that do offer insulation, which is commonly fleece in the world of softshells.
Credit: Zach Lovell

This trade-off between breathability and weather protection is a fundamental challenge in outdoor apparel design. Manufacturers strive to balance these competing properties, but it's important for consumers to understand that no single garment can excel in all areas simultaneously. For this reason, it is important to understand your own specific activity plans and needs before evaluating the range of options available. The right softshell may mean something very different for different shoppers.

While it is unlikely to find a waterproof jacket that also boasts incredible breathability, many options find a happy medium between weather resistance and ventilation.
Credit: Zach Lovell

Softshell jackets shouldn't be considered a substitute for genuine hardshell/rain gear when facing more than a brief thunderstorm, nor should they replace proper insulating layers in extremely cold conditions.

All of our jackets were put through various water resistance testing, and while several offer great protection for shorter periods, a softshell shouldn't replace a true hardshell/rain jacket.
Credit: Zach Lovell

One of the softshell's primary strengths is its breathability, making it ideal for mildly wet or cold environments where it can provide some warmth and weather protection. When choosing a softshell, consider two key questions: What activities will you be doing, and in what climates? Then, determine which layers you plan to use alongside your new softshell. This approach will help you select the most appropriate jacket for your specific needs and intended use.

softshell jacket - do you need a softshell that prioritizes breathability? or are you...
Do you need a softshell that prioritizes breathability? Or are you recreating in more stormy areas and need something with a bit more water resistance?
Credit: Kate Pitts

Packability and Weight in a Softshell Jacket


Finally, it's essential to evaluate how important weight is for your needs. Generally, there is a direct relationship between weight and packability -— the lighter the layer, the more compact it will be when packed.

softshell jacket - no surprise, the bulkiest layers were also typically the heaviest.
No surprise, the bulkiest layers were also typically the heaviest.
Credit: Zach Lovell

We recommend first considering your planned activities and the climates you'll be in, then assessing how much weight matters to you. While warmth and premium weather protection often come with added weight, breathable softshells can be relatively lightweight. It is also important to think through how you will carry extra items when engaged in your activities. Will you have a pack? Will you be storing items at your waist to a belt? Do you need a way to attach the jacket for safekeeping to your body, or can you trust you'll have a pocket to stash it into when needed? Some jackets are designed to stuff easily into their own pockets and may come with an additional loop to make it easy to attach them to a belt or the outside of a pack. This can be very useful, depending on your adventure plans for the day.

softshell jacket - layers that packed down the smallest also typically offered less in...
Layers that packed down the smallest also typically offered less in the ways of features or weather protection performance.
Credit: Zach Lovell

Conclusion


There is no question that softshell jackets are an exceptional class of outdoor garments, as they generally offer more breathability than any other type of jacket. Rest easy knowing we've done the hard part for you: testing the market's top models in real-world settings. Now, all you have to do is find the right option for you based on your fit, activity, and carry needs, as well as your budget.

Zach Lovell, Kate Pitts, Mary Witlacil, and Ryan Huetter